Overdiagnosed and Overtreated: Where’s Mine?

Health Tips / Overdiagnosed and Overtreated: Where’s Mine?

I recently read that mild high blood pressure is turning out to be one of the most overdiagnosed and overtreated health conditions. Untold millions are taking meds they probably don’t need, possibly experiencing unpleasant side effects in the process. The actual history–why we’re all taking inordinate amounts of blood pressure meds–was revealed when it was disclosed that the standards for “normal” blood pressure were set in the 1950s at a huge European medical meeting, underwritten by a pharmaceutical company introducing its latest blood pressure medication.

But the problem of overdiagnosis and overtreatment is certainly not limited to blood pressure. Epidemiological studies conducted throughout the US agree on this. As a nation, Americans are labeled with diagnoses for conditions that may not be particularly dangerous and as a result are encouraged toward medicines and operations that can be risky and may not improve quality of life at all.

Large reviews analyzing conditions as diverse as medical treatment for depression, high cholesterol/blood pressure, surgical intervention for heart disease, uterine fibroids, arthritis, breast lumps–even thyroid and prostate cancers–all end with two basic conclusions: “too many” and “mainly unnecessary.”

The medical term for this excess is overutilization.

Income and insurance drive overutilization

Overutilization (which you can also think of as overtreatment) is at the heart of why the US healthcare system is so egregiously expensive, consuming at last calculation about 17% of our GNP annually, roughly $3.8 trillion—that’s a “T”–or pretty much at least twice that of other developed nations. Not surprisingly, overutilization occurs most predominantly in areas of the country where patients have the highest per capita incomes and the most complete insurance coverage.

Depending on who you interview on the subject, disparate reasons are given for overutilization:

  • If you ask doctors, protected by titanium-strong egos, they’ll place the blame squarely on patients and malpractice lawyers. They say patients ask for more tests than ever, demand that every symptom be immediately diagnosed and treated, and want a quick fix, medication first (the one they just saw on TV) and surgery second. If the physician is unable to provide the desired tests/treatments, the patient will simply go elsewhere and have all her tests repeated.

Doctors also see themselves practicing under a cloud of impending malpractice suits. They’ll test for everything so as not to be blamed for lack of thoroughness. Does the young woman with irritable bowel syndrome really need a third colonoscopy? Does every man who snores really need that sleep study and a CPAP machine?

  • Patients, not surprisingly, blame overutilization on the health care system. Surgeons are one-percenters who do surgical procedures, so if they have to choose between performing or not performing surgery, the patient usually finds herself in an operating room. An extraordinary number of cardiac stents, joint replacements, and prostate/thyroid/breast lump removals have turned out to be useless at improving either quality of life or longevity. (An orthopedic surgeon I know recently joked that the two indications for back surgery were: 1. Does the patient have insurance? and 2. Does the patient have a back? Not funny, I know.)

Money money money money—money!

Take a look at this chart to appreciate how we in the US do more of everything compared to other countries in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), an international economic group. There’s more information at this link.


The term Occam’s Razor refers to a problem-solving principle devised by 14th century philosopher William of Occam. It states that among competing explanations for any problem, the answer with the fewest assumptions should be selected. Other explanations may be correct, but the one with the fewest possibilities is the best.

Often shortened to “the simplest explanation is the best,” if we apply Occam’s Razor to overdiagnosis and overtreatment, the answer with the fewest alternative possibilities is money.

I’ll bet you saw that coming.

Doctors make more money doing operations, necessary or not. Hospitals and their egregiously paid executives make more money when their beds are filled with patients having operations. For example, hospitals do nicely with back surgery. Alternatively, each time a chiropractic physician successful treats a patient with a disc problem, and the patient avoids hospitalization, that’s $100,000 down the tubes.

Pharmaceutical companies make money if you swallow their pills rather than (heaven forfend) living a healthful life. Your local pharmacy makes more money filling your prescriptions than it does selling you cigarettes (although it would prefer to do both… “Happy and Healthy,” remember?). Even such benign and dedicated health care providers as physical therapists, occupational therapists, and psychotherapists all want you to keep coming back for more.

Overutilization permeates everything

Here are some of the latest findings on overutilization and overspending (brace yourself, these are seriously irritating):

  1. EMRs The theory behind the now-required electronic medical records (EMRs) was to enable easy sharing of health data among providers and avoid unnecessary duplication of services. But the system was wrong from the get-go. With more than 500 competing EMR companies, nothing gets shared because no two systems can communicate with each other. Instead, EMRs are essentially used by health insurance companies to determine reimbursement rates to physicians, which appears to mean if your doctor puts more data on your records he’ll receive more money from your insurance company. All EMR systems have automatic templates–big chunks of prewritten information that can be added to your record with a click. Using these templates indiscriminately can add pages of (useless) data to thicken your record and fool the insurance company into thinking you’re receiving all sorts of services you’re really not receiving at all.

In pre-EMR days, a typical consultation from a specialist would be a page or two long, with the most salient notes and recommendations at the end. Handwriting interpretation occasionally required a Rosetta Stone, but we primary docs got used to it. Now the consultations run to about ten pages of electronic junk, even though the specialist herself hasn’t spent a minute longer with you. Since it takes some medical experience to differentiate junk EMR diagnoses from legitimate ones, you could be labelled with (and treated for) a condition you never had in the first place because a physician clicked an inappropriate button on the EMR template.

Example: Nausea from a prescription drug triggers a referral to a gastroenterologist for a gastroscopy instead of simply discontinuing the drug.

  1. The drive-by doc, a new phenomenon in overutilization. In the past, if your surgical procedure needed a second pair of hands, the surgeon would bring in a surgical resident. Most often, your surgeon is in your insurance network. This means his fee is predetermined, and insufficient for his Lamborghini payment. So now, instead of a surgical resident, he deliberately brings in a non-network surgeon, who can charge whatever he likes and you are obligated to pay. (Read this NYT piece to fully grasp the implications.)

Since the fee can be tens of thousands of dollars of course you can’t pay it, but your insurer will cover it under your out-of-network benefit, so you’ll “only” be responsible for 30%. Delighted to be receiving the 70% add-on, your network surgeon and his out-of-network assistant split this largesse and probably won’t bother you for the balance. Your surgeon gets to keep his Lamborghini and if your bill is still overwhelming the financial services department of the hospital will refer you to someone to assist with the refinancing of your condo.

  1. If you’re a user of certain generic medications, you may recently have collapsed in front of your pharmacist when she informed you of new price increases, occasionally as high as 1,000 to 2,000% (this is no typo). The latest new venture among health care vultures is to purchase a small pharmaceutical company making an old generic drug, buy back the distribution rights from other companies, be the only guy in town selling the drug, and charge whatever they like. I’ve previously written about how an injectable med called ACTH went from $9 for a 5-ml vial to $19,000 for the same vial. A small tube of cream for athlete’s foot rocketed from $8 to $120.

This latest rape of the system is being investigated by the Feds, but remembering how well they did with their pre-meltdown investigation of Goldman Sachs, don’t hold your breath.

What all this means is we’ve become too dependent on a health care system that does not have our well-being as its top priority. It brings to mind the late newspaper columnist Mike Royko, who felt Chicago’s motto should be changed from “I Will” to “Where’s Mine?”

And what this really means, as if you don’t know by now, is take care of yourself.

Be well,
David Edelberg, MD

0 thoughts on “Overdiagnosed and Overtreated: Where’s Mine?

    How about alternative medicine treating a disk problem so that it disappears? I used to exercise 35-40 minutes a day to keep my spine in place. I had a degenerated disk and when I’d stop exercising it would go out…three times with excruciating pain. I was treated by a chiropractic physician each of those three times.

    Now, I haven’t done back exercises for around 4 years. I have no problem with a degenerated disk. Why isn’t this recognized by the medical profession? No money is now being taken from my pocket and being put into any physicians purse. Here’s to energy healing work and its cure.

    Carol Ring
    Posted October 14, 2014 at 7:50 am

    I would love to work more with integrative medicine. But, my challenge with alternative health for my specific health issues has been no coverage by insurance. They either don’t cover the practitioners who specialize in my conditions or, in the rare event I find someone in their system, such as an acupuncturist, the insurance company determines the duration and frequency. And it’s never enough. For chronic conditions, alternative treatment can be similar to taking pain meds–you have to keep doing it in order for it to work. That means a life time of potentially, paying out of pocket. The challenge of finding the right treatment specialists, and then often fighting with insurance adds a burden to the chronically ill, that can then cause stress to the illness, an exhausting cycle.

    Beth Murphy
    Posted October 14, 2014 at 3:04 pm

    With all due respect (and I do respect your opinion and knowledge), sometimes one needs to look for zebras and not just think everything is a horse (note: medical schools teach doctors that if one hears hoof-sounds, then think horses, not zebras). I’ve had enough zebras in my life. . .

    Example – I am over 75lbs overweight (have lost quite a bit already), have reflux, am exhausted, and snore. Due to the weight — right? Just lose weight and I’ll be fine. Sleep apnea — right? Get CPAP – right? Well, no. Even when I was at a normal weight, I still had the problems (doctors dismiss THAT part). The snoring is from constant sinus infections due to structural issues and allergies that were missed by one allergist. Reflux is due to a rare condition of LOW HCL in the stomach (measured) and was the cause of a GI carcinoid (which my father also had but died of other causes). Oh, and the exhaustion? It’s from lack of slow wave sleep (only 6% of my sleep is stage 3/4) – with NO APENEA (O2 levels in the upper 90’s during sleep and no stoppage of breathing).

    Given your excellent reputation for “thinking outside the box” (and it is, you saved a friend of mine), I’m surprised about your answers. One thing you missed is THE most important test — one’s inner voice. Mine always was screaming that the doctors were wrong. I tried their ways and just ended up on more and more meds and just as sick. Each one KNEW what I had before any testing was done. One doctor also said that there is no such thing as fibro — it’s usually undiagnosed ankylosing spondylitis. Was put on Humera and it almost killed me.

    Doctors are humans and we need to start working WITH them. Unfortunately, in today’s society, with the insurance companies and for profit health systems trying to squeeze out every cent, doctors have forgotten the art of medicine (or many never learned it) and are forced to practice only the science. They also need to listen to their inner voice — thank goodness I found one that did. . .

    Paula Sims
    Posted October 14, 2014 at 9:31 pm

    Alternative medicine is expensive because it isn’t recognized by insurance companies. Since alternative methods do heal, that means $$$ are taken out of the pockets of insurance companies and traditional health care providers.

    It will take a long time before healing by the body is accepted by the Western medical establishment. They want to keep their ‘walking ATM’s’ alive but not cured.

    My last primary care doctor actually didn’t want me to continue seeing her because I’m healing. I was thrown out of a research project at the National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, Maryland for being severely mentally ill because they also recognized that I am healing.

    How sad. Is money the only thing that matters?

    Thank you Whole Health Chicago for recognizing that alternative practices do make a difference!!

    Carol Ring
    Posted October 15, 2014 at 8:28 am

    Dr Edelberg. I went thru breast cancer treatment in 2009 and now have menigiomas-so of course go to the neurologist and have contrast MRI’s every 6 months. If there is no change, why do I need to get MRI’s every 6 months? For all I know I’ve had the menigiomas since my 20’s! (I am 57 now). I also juice almost every day, take multiple supplements (saw an ND thru all my chemo-most of the supplements are her recommendation–don’t see her anymore-maybe I need to). At what point do I say NO!! Not a headache person, except once had a killer one that is how they found the menigiomas. So tired of all the Dr appts!!! Can you create a Dr Edelberg clone and plant him in Austin, TX???????

    Diane Engelhardt
    Posted October 16, 2014 at 4:48 pm

    How to help with bad allergies

    Dianna Anderson
    Posted April 9, 2015 at 11:37 am

      Hi Dianna. Probably best to meet with one of our functional medicine docs to help you assess contributing factors.

      Dr. R
      Posted April 9, 2015 at 1:58 pm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *