Obama Kvells, Docs Report Misery, and A Modest Proposal

Health Tips / Obama Kvells, Docs Report Misery, and A Modest Proposal

Kvell is a Yiddish word meaning super happy and proud. My grandmother, for example, kvelled when I actually got my MD degree, even though she’d been calling me Dr. Edelberg since I was two.

This week, it was President Obama’s turn to kvell. He’d received great news about the Affordable Care Act (ACA), which, now that it appears to be working, can without embarrassment resume its original eponym, Obamacare. Enrollment has exceeded everyone’s expectations. Despite the near-fatal shaky start of healthcare.gov, since January 1more than eight million Americans got the health coverage they lacked in 2013. To add even more pleasure to the moment, the majority of new enrollees are younger, quite healthy, and not anticipated to financially drain the system.

These eight million are in addition to the three million 18-to-26-year-olds from ACA Part One who, since 2010, have been allowed to remain on their parents’ health insurance policies. That’s a total of 11 million and obviously there are more to come. Even the most jaded anti-Obamacare congressperson knows that any attempt to repeal the ACA now, yanking health insurance from 11 million people, would be political suicide.

But all is not rosy

Doctors these days aren’t kvelling about much of anything. Last week’s The Daily Beast had a chilling article entitled “How Being A Doctor Became The Most Miserable Profession” and while most Beast articles are followed by a dozen or so comments, when I last looked this one had a kite tail of 429 decidedly strong opinions. Writer Daniela Drake, MD, an internist like me who apparently sought happier pastures as both an MBA and professional writer, begins her dismal piece based on surveys taken of physicians themselves. She emphasizes that the misery is pretty much confined to primary care physicians (PCPs)–family practitioners, internists, ob-gynies, and pediatricians.

On the opposite extreme, specialists (especially surgical specialists) who are pretty much protected from day-to-day headaches and earning three or four times the income of a PCP are significantly more cheerful. For example, to get reimbursed for a $5,000 surgical procedure, a surgeon completes one claim form, submits it with his surgical procedure report, and waits for his check. To earn a comparable sum, a PCP needs to see 50 patients and submit 50 claims to any of a dozen insurers. Half of these will be denied on a technicality, requiring staff to fax over medical records to the insurer. Weeks to months later, a check, substantially less than the doctor’s professional fee, will arrive.

Simply put, says Dr. Drake, being a physician is now the second most suicidal occupation, the doctors in her piece describing their experience as PCPs as a miserable and humiliating undertaking. Not surprisingly, nine out of ten PCPs actively discourage their kids from becoming doctors. Medical students are shunning primary care like the plague, PCPs are retiring early, and physician-MBA programs (promising doctors a way into the more lucrative field of medical management) are flourishing.

Why the misery?

Because PCPs are left with everything other doctors rarely bother with, Dr. Drake calls them the janitors of the health care system. First, look at the numbers. A surgeon can only perform so many procedures in a day and then goes home, leaving residents and nurses to handle post-op care. I had hip surgery several years ago. When I woke up, the post-op nurse said my surgeon had departed for his Caribbean vacation while I was still under anesthesia, a resident left behind to sew me up.

With 11 million new enrollees in the ACA system, predictions are that a primary care doctor can have a workload of from 2,000 to 3,000 patients, far more than any physician should attempt to handle. That translates to 24 to 30 patients a day, keeping in mind that some who have multiple medical problems can’t be properly treated in their allotted 15-minute time slot. And of course each of these patients has an insurance claim for the doctor’s staff to complete, with adversarial insurance companies that delay payment by requesting medical records for review. Further bogging down the day are seemingly endless forms for doctors to complete, letters to write, pre-authorization phone calls, and still more forms for drugs, lab tests, x-rays, and referrals to specialists.

Add to this the multipage, work-related disability forms and the letters we’re asked to write: excuses from jury duty, pets on airplanes, ergonomic chairs for work, added time for SAT exams. Plus the usual dozens of lab test results to review and phone calls with specialists, social workers, family members, etc.

And hovering over each of the hundreds of daily decisions a doctor makes is the implied threat of a malpractice suit. Every physician in America gets at least one of these in her career and while most turn out to be frivolous and ultimately dismissed, the psychological trauma to a doctor can be devastating.

Little wonder Dr. Drake became an MBA!

It’s beginning to look like Obamacare is only going to increase doctors’ stress. Already PCPs are anxious about what so far seems like truly unreasonable demands beyond the increased patient load.

We all got our first taste of the ACA with the electronic medical records (EMRs) requirement. Install EMRs or face financial penalties, they told us.  If the public thought healthcare.gov was unwieldy, it’s nothing compared to EMRs. In a recent survey, 85% of PCPs confess to loathing EMRs, whose endless clicks and data entry commandments add at the least one full hour to an already packed workday.

As the ACA goes full force, EMRs add a “Big Brother is watching you” component. Your medical records will be (anonymously) connected to automated quality review monitoring and endlessly scanned. These records require dozens of additional clicks to fill in data whose presence or absence will affect your doctor’s reimbursement profile. For example, if a practice fails to show that a required percentage of women aren’t receiving mammograms, or that cholesterol levels aren’t brought down to the “healthy standard” (by prescribing more statin drugs), the doctor’s income suffers, regardless of whether women want the mammograms or any patient wants to be on statins. Standardization becomes the name of the game. If your cholesterol is 220 and you’re not on a statin, you’ll get a letter that your doctor is not providing “standard” care while your doctor gets a financial penalty.

If enough PCPs walk away (or become MBAs and dictate terms to the rest of us), your primary care provider may well become that nurse practitioner on duty at Walgreens, CVS, Target, or Walmart. Nurse practitioners give excellent care for day-to-day stuff, like sore throats and immunizations, but will off-load anything remotely complex to the PCP you’ve selected from your network. They also off-load the boring janitorial stuff, like filling out forms, writing letters, and getting your pre-auths. You can expect about the same relationship with a Walgreens nurse practitioner as you would with your Starbuck’s barista. She’ll be pleasant and competent, but won’t remember your name. And please don’t ask for her answering service number or for Walgreens to page her during her off hours.

How to cope with this projected PCP shortage

My modest proposal is to find a good chiropractic physician and use her as your PCP. There are several compelling reasons to consider this:

  • Chiropractic physicians, with the exception of pharmacology and surgery, have the same training in sciences as medical doctors. They can recognize signs and symptoms of organic illness, know the limitations of their expertise, and are taught when to refer to medical doctors.
  • Your chiropractic physician (and her staff) will get to know you as a person. You’ll have a set of your records on file in one place, including details on your health history.
  • Chiropractic physicians know how to perform a physical exam. In addition, they can do very sophisticated musculoskeletal/neurological testing that I was simply never taught. In addition, most chiropractic offices now draw blood, order x rays and scans, and refer to surgical specialists.
  • Most chiropractic physicians also have a relationship with an MD (usually their own). Alternatively, they can fax their evaluation to your PCP for uploading into your electronic medical records. Some electronic systems even allow you upload your chiro office visit to your online medical records by yourself.
  • Any time you see a doctor—an MD (medical doctor), DO (doctor of osteopathy), or DC (doctor of chiropractic)–keep in mind that most symptoms aren’t caused by disease, but rather by unhealthful lifestyles. Most headaches are caused by stress and most digestive problems by poor food choices. Sadly, because they’re so pressed for time, medical doctors treat symptoms with prescription drugs rather than teaching lifestyle changes like healthful eating, stress reduction, and exercise. Instead of endlessly relying on prescription drugs (the side effects of which are the fourth leading cause of death), chiropractors are geared toward nutritional therapies, diet changes, body therapies, and other health-oriented techniques.
  • Between the ages of 18 and 60, most of your medical problems will likely have their origin in your musculoskeletal system. It’s the first system to peter out as you age, and here chiropractors are in their element, balancing your body, teaching you exercises, and offering a wide variety of treatments that are not drug-based.
  • PCPs refer patients far too quickly and too often to medical specialists. Although specialists are necessary, their perspective is a narrow one confined to their area of expertise. The result is that many patients receive too many complex and potentially dangerous diagnostic tests and unnecessary surgeries for symptoms that might have been treatable with simple lifestyle changes.
  • Chiropractic physicians consistently receive “highly satisfied” ratings from patients. This is because they generally spend more time with them than other physicians, really getting to know their patients well. Virtually every chiropractic physician I’ve ever known will squeeze you in if you need to be seen quickly, and virtually all have a relationship with an MD they can call on if actual medical intervention is needed.
  • Finally—and importantly–unlike the self-reported misery among PCPs, surveys among chiropractic physicians reveal just the opposite: feelings of personal satisfaction, acceptable levels of stress, and a strong sense of being beneficial to society.

I’ve been working closely with two chiropractic physicians, Paul Rubin and Cliff Maurer, for years. In fact, when Dr. Rubin and I founded WholeHealth Chicago, we learned that ours was the first partnership in Illinois between an MD and DC. Many of our patients actually use Paul and Cliff as their primary care physicians, calling on me (or on Drs. Kelley or Donigan) when the situation appears to need medical intervention.

All in all, I’m glad our president is kvelling, but saddened that the word misery is now linked with being a doctor. This just means, as always, take care of yourself and…

Be well,
David Edelberg, MD

0 thoughts on “Obama Kvells, Docs Report Misery, and A Modest Proposal

    Dr. Edelberg,

    A well written article indeed. Thank you for bringing further awareness to this significant and most commonly misunderstood issue. Drawing attention to the increasing burden of PCP’s is a necessity if we are to educate the public about the nature of their modern healthcare system. Moreover, utilizing chiropractors is an admirable and sustainable practice. A chiropractor myself, I am critical of our profession and its place within modern medicine. I look forward to the positive sentiments shared by medical doctors like yourself regarding the chiropractic profession. I hope that our colleagues and the public alike continue to educate themselves, and others, searching for solutions to the ever evolving healthcare landscape. In an economy that rewards the specialization of doctors with significant financial promise, coupled with insurance companies that attempt to dictate and decrease both treatment and reimbursement, co-management is more critical than ever to ensure patient centered care and favorable outcomes. If we are to continue serving our patients with best practices, addressing the root cause of their symptoms, what you have proposed will be the lynchpin for future success in this matter. Thank you for your support!

    Dr. Ouellette
    Posted June 5, 2014 at 6:00 pm

    Thank you for these blog posts. They give insight to the broken health care system that the mainstream media is currently ignoring.

    Posted May 28, 2014 at 2:16 am

    Great story – I LOVE my chiropractor – but to clarify, taking away millions of people’s healthcare would be impossible – unless you’re a Democrat.

    How many millions where thrown off their paid for healthcare with ObamaCare? Well, the White House won’t tell you.

    Posted May 8, 2014 at 11:27 pm

    Great article. As a newer chiropractor in town, I have yet to build a relationship with any of the PCP’s in town. I guess I better do that soon, as they may need my help to lower their workload. Any suggestions on how to connect with a PCP with their busy schedules? Letter? Email? Phone call? Drop in face to face?
    Much appreciated,
    Dr. Z

    Dr. Lance Zimney DC
    Posted May 6, 2014 at 5:53 pm

      Hi Doc. Send a report of your examination findings to your patient’s PCP along with the care you’ve recommended. This letter should be written in a manner to include the PCP’s feedback in an effort to enhance your patient’s overall outcome. Obviously, ask your patient’s permission to contact their PCP but most are happy that you’re willing to do so. Relationships often take time to develop; be patient.

      Dr. R
      Posted May 7, 2014 at 7:40 pm
    Chiropractors as family doctors preferred because of Obama-care | matteo chiropractic and physical therapy
    Posted May 6, 2014 at 10:07 am

    […] How to cope with this projected primary care physician shortage … find a good chiropractic ph… […]

    Chiropractors as Family Doctors | Dr. Stefanie's Blog
    Posted May 5, 2014 at 12:35 am

    While I fully concur that there needs to be a viable role for chiropractors that is 1) science-based and 2) within mainstream healthcare, the elephant in the room is that despite the 4 years of lecture-based training in the “same sciences” that DCs get we DO NOT get any standardized post-graduate training that would be equivalent to what MDs or DOs get. No residency. Huge problem if you are talking about trusting a musculo-skeletal profession to address internal disorders.

    Posted May 2, 2014 at 9:50 am

    Outstanding article. You are spot on about chiropractic and lifestyle management. My personal experience is our culture has become the “easy way out”, (pain pills, muscle relaxers, and steroids) instead of lifetsyle changes and taking RESPONSIBILITY FOR THEIR OWN HELATH.Keep up the good work and I am sure a few more will “see the light”

    Mark Cotney, DC
    Posted April 30, 2014 at 10:36 pm

    Dear Dr. Edelberg, I want to thank you for writing this poignant article about the changes in the healthcare industry to incorporate Obamacare and how it affects the consumer as well as the doctor. I read the comments, and I realize as a practitioner, I am not alone in my struggle to stay in business and maintain quality healthcare that allows me to spend time with my patients. It is unfortunate, that for the alternative practitioner that accepts the more complicated, chronic cases, that a cash practice may be the only solution for adequate reimbursement. I am afraid that our healthcare industry will never be the same.

    Dr. Kimberly Beith
    Posted April 29, 2014 at 9:36 am

    Hi Rob
    Thanks for the great links!
    Smart? No, just made the best decision of my professional career when I partnered with a chiropractor

    Dr E
    Posted April 23, 2014 at 6:38 pm

    Dr Edelberg- thank you for your accurate portrayal of the future for PCPs and their patients. I thank you also for your kind words concerning my profession. I am a chiropractor in the Chicago suburbs. I share your concerns about the future of all solo practices. The OIG hangs a constant threat over all our heads and their ability to ask for money back for services approved and paid for up to 3 years ago, is forcing many of us to reexamine the risk:reward ratio of taking insurance. I believe the 2-3 year outcome of these actions will be very large groups of practitioners in Metro areas and very few entrepreneurs anywhere. This is a bad trend for many reasons. Even from a strictly financial perspective, our country is supposed to boost and celebrate the local business owner… not feeling the love.

    Dr Victoria Myler
    Posted April 23, 2014 at 6:19 pm

    I have to say…. “Gee how did you get so smart!!!”
    The American Chiropractic Association, along with the International Chiropractic Association, The Association of Chiropractic Colleges, and the Congress of Chiropractic State Association appear to agree with you based on the following information posted on the ACA’s Website. The case for full inclusion of Chiropractic in the Health care system without discrimination: So Gee – However you got so smart – you have alot of people agreeing with you. Thanks for posting this very great article I hope you enjoy the links that agree with what you have said.

    Dr. Rob Sheely
    Posted April 23, 2014 at 10:02 am

    I think this article is great! It would be wonderful if the majority of the population realized this. However it is extremely unfortunate that certain states like NY which I live has no possible future with this possible career changing aspect. Since in NY chiropractors can only related everything back to the spine.

    Dianne Finkelstein
    Posted April 23, 2014 at 6:32 am

    Obamacare may be good for some, but so far for me, it just sucks more money from my pocket even though I am healthy. The last time I had a visit to the doctor or physician or hospital was in 2008 when I saw you, Dr. E., to check on food allergies. But I now have individual health insurance with my wife with $11,000 annual deductible, and the premium doubled since last year. Maybe the coverage is better, but for someone who uses so little healthcare, this is just lining the pockets of insurance companies with no value provided to me. Oh yes, and I tried to add a HSA to my existing policy, but now that can only be done during open enrollment periods or with a qualifying event. So choice has been dramatically limited as well. Just exactly who benefits from Obamacare?

    Posted April 22, 2014 at 5:38 pm

    This was a great article Dr. Edelberg – clear concise, full of humor and truth and even with the bad news, a positive outlook in general (especially for the DC’s!). I’m actually just about to forward it to my chiropractor.
    Thanks again!

    Posted April 22, 2014 at 5:07 pm

    Thanks for the info. I’ve been seeing my chiropractor for years now as my PCP only I just pay out of pocket. I consider my medical insurance I pay for through work to be more “catastrophic” insurance.

    Posted April 22, 2014 at 3:00 pm

    These are the same ills plaguing teachers in our one-size-fits-all public education system. Teach to the test, fill out myriad forms to satisfy that same big brother – whatever you do, don’t teach critical thinking skills. The lawyers, MBAs and bean counters have turned education and health care into corporate enterprises. Kvell? Not quite – all we can do is kvetch.

    Posted April 22, 2014 at 2:55 pm

    Interesting article. Thanks, Dr. Edelberg.

    Posted April 22, 2014 at 11:38 am

    PCP misery certainly understandable with that workload / stress…wow! Interesting info; great write-up here, Dr. E.

    Nina M.

    Nina M.
    Posted April 22, 2014 at 10:54 am

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *