2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Do We Actually Need More Malpractice Attorneys?

Although doctors still stiffen visibly in the presence of the word “malpractice,” today fewer cases than ever are filed. Over the past 20 years, instead of settling claims quickly, malpractice insurance companies fought back. This turned the tide as fewer and fewer cases ruled in favor of the plaintiff.

Malpractice attorneys, paid on a contingency basis, receive fees only if they win. Lose a case and a malpractice attorney walks away empty-handed after investing sometimes tens of thousands in unpaid hours and out-of-pocket costs. It’s not a profession for the faint of heart.

Personally (and remember, I’m in the minority here), as much as I’d dread being on the receiving end of a med-mal suit, you as a patient need to be able to sue for damages against a physician or hospital that botches your life or kills a loved one. The hovering threat of med-mal is the only available system that effectively acts as behavioral modification therapy to prevent your doctor from doing a slapdash job.

There are lots of myths about med-mal, including the idea that rising premiums escalate health care costs (untrue–premiums have been steady for years), that doctors are able to self-police and don’t need the specter of a med-mal attorney (untrue–there are almost no professional disciplinary actions taken against doctors), and finally that juries give outrageously high awards (untrue–99.5% are less than $1 million).

Death by healthcare
This support of medical malpractice attorneys might seem like a strange way to begin a Health Tip until you consider a freshly published article from the British Medical Journal. A careful analysis of hospitalizations showed that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US. You read that correctly: heart disease is first, cancer second, and death by healthcare error third.

I don’t think physicians were too surprised at this. The old idea that doctors are able to bury their mistakes likely goes back to the Middle Ages, but don’t take “burial” literally. Researchers realized that the US healthcare system buries its mistakes on your death certificate rather than in the ground. No matter who’s signing off on your departure, no one (doctor, funeral director, coroner) lists the cause of death as “medical error.”

The current medical diagnostic coding system, called ICD-10, was devised to maximize insurance billing, not to collect statistics. Although there are more than 69,000 possible ICD-10 diagnoses—from appendicitis to Zika—there’s no diagnostic code for medical error. If there is no code, there’s no reimbursement, and of course someone writing it in by hand does nothing but open the writer to the wrath of bosses or peers.

By the numbers
To reach their extraordinary conclusion that medical errors constitute the third leading cause of death, researchers examined four previous studies that analyzed medical death rates from 2000 to 2008.  Based on 35,416,020 hospitalizations, they found that 9.5% of deaths were caused by some sort of medical error. This comes to about 250,000 deaths per year, roughly the population of Louisville, Kentucky. Coming in third, medical error managed to knock chronic lung disease to fourth place.  

But listen up. These researchers were examining only hospitalizations. What about medical deaths outside hospitals?

Also pretty frightening was the conclusion, published in the Journal of the American Medical Association a few years ago, that correctly taken prescription drugs are the sixth leading cause of death in the US.

While we’re at it, let’s move from medical deaths and drug-related deaths to the word “wounded,” as in medical wounds or wounded by health care. We never use the word wounded in healthcare statistics, but perhaps we should. Instead we encounter “wounded” in the context of military war casualties. By clicking to the Wikipedia entry listing total casualties for every US war, you’ll see a column for “Total US Deaths,” another for “Total US Wounded,” and then, adding the two together, “Total US Casualties.” Traveling down the list, war by messy war, it averages 3.0 to 3.5 wounded for every death.

Could this multiple apply to health care? I don’t see why not.  Tripling the 250,000 deaths would bring us to 750,000 Americans annually “wounded” by health care.

The walking wounded, or worse
As I read over this chart of wasted and wounded lives, I couldn’t help but carry the military analogy a step further. Consider yourself, the patient, as the common foot soldier and the healthcare system itself as one enormous battlefield. Instead of military fatigues, you’re in a hospital gown. You may survive, be lucky enough to call yourself a veteran, and if whatever you had is now gone you’ll enjoy the veteran’s benefit of improved longevity.

But if something goes wrong you’ll be among the wounded or the killed. In war, both sides are controlled by the top brass, made up of politicians and generals. In our healthcare system, the top brass are doctors and hospital administrators on one side and the insurance industry on the other. The top brass, in war or in healthcare, are rarely casualties.

How many millions emerge from their healthcare experience worse than when they started? How many patients survived surgery, a drug reaction, or misguided psychotherapy but were never really healthy again?

Shocked as we are by the idea of medical-related deaths coming in third, we’d be truly overwhelmed if ever a survey were taken among the survivors of our healthcare system. Something simple, like “Has any encounter with health care left you with more medical problems than you started with?” “If yes, what happened?”

Besides prompting you to wonder where you put your Xanax, there are two take-aways from this Health Tip:

  • Your chances of becoming a health care statistic (killed or wounded) are considerably reduced by avoiding the system as much as possible. By now, I hope you know you can do this by eating healthfully, exercising regularly, and making a point to reduce stress, avoid tobacco, wear a seat belt, etc. It’s your body—take care of it yourself.
  • I told you we might need more malpractice attorneys.

Be well,
David Edelberg, MD

Leave a Comment


  1. calle says:

    Dr David,

    You are a true hero, among many.
    Thanks, we avoid at all cost.
    We have a wounded child and we now do our own healing and eating of healthy foods etc.
    Blessings, Calle

  2. John Cox says:

    This is brave and informative. I recommend the Washington Post article as well.

  3. Tina Hepworth says:

    V.good advice Dr.E, but in IN it seems that even the threat of malpractice doesn’t prevent Drs doing a slapdash job,because the system is such that the Drs know the lawyers , are able to choose their own support on the panel and the patient has to find a Dr. who will stand up and say “yes” this Dr. caused harm, which is virtually unheard of! Malpractice cases for severe injury rarely if ever win in IN. Every state varies. In a nutshell, here’s my experiences: hip cartilage torn during v. minor surgical procedure; had to have hip replacement. Then, surgeon misaligns joint. Year later have to have another one put in corre ctly. Have an AF ablation and end up with chipped tooth/ulcerated throat, huge bump on back of head, which becomes infected , plus after having been strapped to flat gurney for 12 hrs had sudden onset knee pain, which I then discovered was another damaged hip under anesthesia, and resulted in another hip replacement! Each procedure I walked into perfectly well, active and playing hard racketball twice a week-no hip issues whatsoever. A few of the comments I had from the various Drs :”Nothing happened”, “that was how I was taught to do the procedure” “what do you think I did-drop you?”, “it was a simple grade 1 intubation-I’ve never seen anything like this before”!!!! Oh and after reporting issues for 3 weeks after a major 12 hr surgery, I was admitted via the ER ( at NWM) in a state of sepsis, and my surgeon says” you don’t look as sick as I thought you would from your notes”!!!!! Grand finale…..was having a very minot procedure, was put to sleep, and woke up to hear the surgeon and anesthesioloist shouting at each other because he wast ready to start! I don’t believe I’ve been singled out -this is happening all the time. Severe injury is as common as death in hospitals. I’ve clearly used up my 9 lives and it will take an awful lot to get me thru’ the doors of another hospital/surgery center ever again!!!The result: 3 years of post op recovery before I could be really active again, and a year recovering from a near fatal post-op infection , after the 2 weeks in hospital on 3 strong anti-biotics 24/7, ..not to mention the chipped front tooth-v. minor point! It was lies, lies, and more lies, and not one semblance of an apology!!!

  4. Ruth paulson says:

    Must read. Excellent article.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

BIRTHDAY

Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our

patient-portal

The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

Upcoming Workshops

**Pain Relief with Therapy Balls
Tuesday, May 21, 2019, 6 – 7:30 PM
With Yoga and Movement Therapist Renee Zambo, RYT
Course Fee: $65.00
(includes WHC Myofascial Release Kit, $40 value)

Does that same spot in your neck, shoulders, back or hips seem to bother you every day? Do you have joint aches and pains in the hands and feet? Would you like to learn ways to alleviate that pain and tension?

Join us for this workshop if you experience:
• Chronic Pain • Arthritis • Back, Neck, Shoulder or Hip Pain • Muscular Tension • Injuries • Plantar Fasciitis • Scar Tissue • Tension Headaches • And More!

Space is limited and registration is required.
Please register online.
Call the Center for additional information at (773) 296-6700
More>>

Recent Health Tips

  • I Feel So Inflamed!

    And among other symptoms, indeed she was. Julia, a bright 40-something, had written “fatigue,” “pain,” “bad digestion,” and “brain fog” on her WholeHealth Chicago intake paperwork. She’d been ill for years and brought with her two binders full of medical info on herself. The thicker of these contained accumulated medical records, lab tests, imaging studies, and physician summaries. At first glance, it appeared the various Read More

  •  “I’m Really Confused About Sun Exposure”

    Julie was heading for an all-inclusive week in Cancun to loll on a vast expanse of beach, soaking up rays and having someone named Juan bring her endless pina coladas (she planned to get her money’s worth). Sounded pretty nice to me. After months of Chicago overcast/gray, it seemed like a perfect way to put seasonal affective disorder to bed for the winter. Julie was Read More

  • Here’s What You Should Know About Lyme Disease

    In H.G. Wells’s novel (and Steven Spielberg’s movie) War of the Worlds, aliens invade Earth, fully intending to destroy it. Despite our best efforts to defend ourselves, we’re clearly losing until suddenly all the aliens start dying off. Scientists later discover the aliens had no immunity to Earth’s bacteria. The evil aliens were out of their territory and paid the price with their lives. With the Read More

April Sale: 20% off Four Elements Organic Herbals Tea Blends

Celebrate the arrival of spring with 20% off Four Elements Organic Herbals tea blends. Based in central Wisconsin, Four Elements has been dedicated to organic growing for nearly three decades. These herbal tea blends are made with their hand-harvested organic herbs and packaged in oxygen-bleached paper. Purchase now       More Info