2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Doctors and Lab Tests

When I was in pre-med (back in the Pleistocene Era, to many of you), I worked as a lab technician in a small hospital. All those blood and urine tests you’ve had whose results are now fully automated were once processed slowly and painstakingly by hand (mine among them). The so-called metabolic profile of about 20 tests that today takes a few seconds to complete would have occupied me for nearly a full workday.

Because of high labor and time costs, doctors back then ordered tests very carefully. In fact, to emphasize the labor involved, during my years in medical school doctors had to learn how to process blood tests, perform blood counts (manually, with a hand counter), and interpret blood smear slides and Pap tests. Today doctors are taught the chemistry behind these tests, but since it’s all automated they don’t learn the mechanics.

The concept of “labs” was relatively new back then. Physicians ordered tests primarily to confirm a diagnosis they’d already made by listening to their patient’s medical history and performing a physical exam. For a doctor to order reams of tests to see what might emerge as abnormal was considered the sign of a lazy clinician.

Over the past several years, the medical profession has been taking itself to task for allowing lab tests (and x-rays and CT and MRI scans) do their thinking for them, and they’re quite uncomfortable with what they’re finding.

Far (far!) too many tests are being done on patients, often with little return.

• First, as you might imagine, tests of any stripe are extremely expensive. Most of the results you see on a typical lab report are unnecessary, but the doctor can’t not order them because they’re part of a bundled package. I can’t say to the lab, “I want only four tests out of that package of 20,” because they deliberately price the four I want to exceed the price of the 20 in the bundle. And because we don’t have comprehensive shared electronic medical records in the US, the duplication of tests is simply astonishing.

• Second, all this ordering of tests may not be that good for you, the patient. We’re only now beginning to appreciate the high radiation exposure from CT scans. Women have undergone unnecessary breast biopsies–and men unnecessary prostate biopsies–for the most minimal of lab abnormalities. And, sadly, when an abnormal result (often on an unordered test) pops up, doctors feel compelled to order even more tests to follow up on it, or refer you to a specialist for another bevy of tests. By the time you hear, “Well, it turned out to be nothing,” you’re a nervous wreck.

In medical school we were endlessly warned “Treat your patient, not her lab test,” but too many doctors seem to have forgotten this, starting patients on a lifetime of meds to lower a slightly high cholesterol reading that could easily be handled by diet changes or labeling patients with serious illnesses based on a blood tests that have high percentages of false-positive test results. During the decades that a nearby university center “didn’t believe in fibromyalgia,” I saw dozens of women diagnosed (wrongly) with lupus and started on potentially dangerous medications because doctors treated their lab test, not them.

• Third (and this is not an original thought), I believe that having access to literally thousands of tests–and having a third party (health insurance) pick up the tab–makes doctors intellectually lazy. When new patients arrive at WholeHealth Chicago with enormous stacks of medical records, it’s obvious that doctors ordered many multiples of the same tests, with costs spiraling to thousands of dollars. As I read through piles of test reports, almost all of them completely and repeatedly normal, I have to wonder: Were all these tests ordered because the doctor didn’t have anything better to do with his or her mind?

If you’re thinking doctors do this for the money, you’d be wrong. The dollars for these tests go to hospitals and the lab testing facilities. Does a physician order all these tests fearing a malpractice suit? Yes, according to surveys that’s behind some of it. But ultimately, all this test ordering came about because it’s what the conventional health care system limited itself to. Chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists, and homeopaths don’t order endless tests and yet they manage to make an astonishing number of people well without bankrupting them.

The answer, of course, is balance. Once your doctor has ordered the few tests needed to rule out some serious condition that might be causing your symptoms, or ordered some simple tests to screen you for diabetes or cholesterol problems, rather than ordering more tests, he or she should consider listening to you more carefully and perhaps suggesting you see an alternative practitioner for relief of your symptoms.

Don’t ever be afraid to question your physician when the only suggestion is “Well, let’s get a few more test results and see.”

Be well,

David Edelberg, MD

Leave a Comment


  1. Patrice says:

    Each blog entry covers an important topic and the case
    study examples bring the issue alive. Thank you so much for taking
    the time and putting in the effort each week to share. I’ve passed
    on several of your entries to friends and family.

  2. gene goldring says:

    hi david,
    loved this newsletter, which arrived at good time for me. my internist ordered parathyroid ultrasound because my PTH was 66, above normal range by “1”. calcium was 9.1, absolutely normal. yes, i have osteopenia so i understand the rationale but how do you have parathyroid disease with a normal calcium ? i asked him if i really needed the test, told him i would sign a disclaimer stating that not doing it was my choice and against his advice, and he asked me to please do the test, that he would be more comfortable. i did so, even though i have a high deductible blue cross policy and knew it would be out of pocket. test was normal, and i haven’t gotten the bill yet…………best, gene

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

BIRTHDAY

Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our

patient-portal

The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

BIRTHDAY

Upcoming Workshops

**Finding Your Calm
Tuesday June 5, 6:00 – 7:30pm
Christine Savas, LPC & Renee Zambo, RYT
Fee: $65 (including take-home materials)

Are you looking for ways to wind down amidst a hectic schedule?  Do you want to learn how to deal with ongoing stress?  Do you need tools to help you relax, but aren’t sure how or where to start? Join WholeHealth Chicago’s Clinical Psychotherapist Christine Savas and Yoga Therapist Renee Zambo for an evening of education on the importance of slowing down.

Space is limited and registration is required.
Please register online or by calling (773) 296-6700
More>>

 

**Shamanic Healing Clinic
Monday, June 11, 2018
with Katie Oberlin, HTCP
30-Minute Sessions ~ $40.00 (regularly $55.00)

Summer is just around the corner with the Solstice approaching on June 21st. Shamanically speaking, this is a great time to harness the power of the Earth element to ground your intentions and welcome it as a container for taking action in positive ways.

Experience a shamanic healing session.
Have you been thinking about new ways to address your health? Or build new relationships? Or be more authentically present in your work?

Take this opportunity to support this time of transition from Spring into Summer with an individual 30-minute session.

Registration
By appointment only, June 11, 12 – 5 pm
Half-hour session for $40 (regular price $55)
Please call 773-296-6700 to register.
More>>

 

***Vaginal Rejuvenation Workshop
Thursday, June 14, 2018;  6:00 – 8:00 PM
Mari Stecker, LAc & Renee Zambo, RYT
Fee: $65

Are you experiencing vaginal dryness? Or pain with intercourse? Have you been told you have vaginal atrophy due to menopauseAre you frustrated because you believe your sex life is overWell, it doesn’t have to be!

Come learn easy, non-pharmaceutical, non-hormonal, low cost techniques that you can do at home to help alleviate vaginal dryness, atrophy, thinning of vaginal skin and/or painful intercourse.

Space is limited and registration is required.
Please register online or by calling (773) 296-6700
More>>

 

Recent Health Tips

  • Controversial Diagnosis #3: Candida Overgrowth Syndrome

    Patients come to WholeHealth Chicago regularly with this common refrain: “You’re the fourth (or seventh or tenth) doctor I’ve seen. I feel terrible but am always told that my tests are normal and there’s nothing wrong with me. Recently I read about Candida overgrowth and the symptoms seem to fit me exactly. But the doctors I’ve seen all tell me there’s no such illness.” These Read More

  • Controversial Diagnosis #2: Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

    In the mid-1980s, two outbreaks of what appeared to be infectious mononucleosis appeared in the US. Unlike typical mono, which caused exhaustion for a few weeks, people with this type were left in a permanent state of fatigue, with low-grade fevers, swollen lymph glands, muscle aches, and poor focus/concentration. In some cases, the fever and lymph gland swelling subsided, but the utter exhaustion persisted. Because Read More

  • Controversial Diagnosis #1: Fibromyalgia

    I encountered my first significant controversial diagnosis when we opened WholeHealth Chicago in the mid-1990s. The concept of combining conventional and alternative medicine was new to the Midwest and right away we began seeing patients who came to us with chronic symptoms but no solid diagnosis. One group that stood out was made up of primarily women who had longstanding and severe widespread muscle pain Read More

May Sale: 20% Off Metagenics Gut Health Formulas

In honor of World Digestive Health Day on May 29th, some of our favorite gut-supportive formulas are 20% off this month! You’ve asked us to put these on sale and we’ve listened, but please pace yourselves – you have all month to take advantage of this great deal! More>>