2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Knowledge Base

Welcome to our extensive library of articles on health concerns and conditions, alternative therapies, nutrition, nutritional supplements, and much more. Acupuncture / Traditional Chinese Medicine Aging Allergies & Food Sensitivities Alternative Therapies Big Pharma Evils Bone Health Candida (Yeast) and Parasites Cardiovascular Health Case Studies Chiropractic & Physical Medicine Dermatology Digestion Diseases Ear, Nose & Throat Environmental Sensitivities Eye Care Fibromyalgia & Chronic Fatigue Fitness & Exercise Health Insurance Issues Healthy Lifestyle Immune System Inflammation Integrative Medicine Lyme Disease & Morgellons Men's Health Mental Health Nutrition, Nutritional Supplements, Vitamins, & Herbal Remedies Pain Management Sexual Health Thyroid, Adrenal, & Sex Hormone Issues Weight Issues Women's Health

JAMA Reports Bribing Your Doc Could Improve Care (You Might Not Want These Details)

Two separate articles appeared this week in JAMA (the Journal of the American Medical Association) reporting that financial incentives either to individual physicians or group practices might improve the overall quality of care delivered to patients. I guess it’s human nature, especially viewed through the eyes of a lifetime Chicagoan like myself, to think, “Well of course bribes work (sorry, financial incentives)…unless you’re caught.”

You slip the guy with the snowplow $20 and the street in front of your house gets cleared before your neighbor around the corner. Generally, 20 bucks to your mailman ensures your copy of Vogue won’t be buried in a snow bank.

But gosh, do we really need such thinking when it comes to our health? Wasn’t there some sort of oath taken after medical school graduation that excluded this sort of pay-for-play (perfected by literally dozens of Illinois politicians over the years)? Apparently not.

“Financial-based performance enhancement”
Large sums are being spent on both sides of the Atlantic to find out if doctors do a better job if their palms have been greased before they slide on the surgical gloves.

The answer, of course, is that whether you want really good seats for the next Stones gig or you want blood pressures lowered, bribery pays. Is anyone really surprised that doctors are exempt? For a bit of extra cash your doc (also, BTW, your pharmacist and local hospital) will go the extra mile for you. Naturally, it’s not called a bribe. Now it’s a (get this) “financial-based performance enhancement.”

The two recent JAMA studies, and other similar ones published over the past few years, all work the same way. Investigators select one or more readily measurable goals for physicians to meet. Blood pressure control, for example, or lowering cholesterol or hemoglobin A1C (a blood test that monitors diabetes management). In a hospital, it’s usually early discharge days or post-op surgical wound care. In nursing homes, measurable nutritional improvements among the frail elderly.

Divide the participating physicians, hospitals, and nursing homes into two groups. Set an end point like “patient blood pressure under good control within three months.” Pay each doc in one group a C-note for every patient of theirs meeting the goal. The other group of docs gets nothing–ashes, cinders, and their usual not-unsubstantial paycheck.

If your doc knows he’s getting the $100, he’ll make sure your blood pressure plummets (maybe even if you didn’t have high blood pressure in the first place). Wait, did I say that? I’m sorry for even suggesting such nefarious behavior is possible.

EMRs smooth the way
The current (and mandatory) switch-over to electronic medical records (EMRs) now lays your health wide open to the Big Brothers of the government and health insurance industry. Don’t bother with any hand-wringing about this–they’ve known about your health status for years. You probably don’t remember signing a release form when you got your group insurance. You were so happy to be employed you’d sign anything. And you did.

With EMRs, observing and monitoring a physician’s activity is pretty basic stuff, especially in a big group practice in which all doctors enter data into a common system. Smaller practices like WholeHealth Chicago are more challenging to monitor since, amazingly enough, no two EMRs are alike and interpractice communication is virtually impossible. But yes, when financial incentives were in place, researchers discovered that when promised a crisp hundred dollar bill for getting a patient’s numbers down, the doc went that extra mile. Better yet, the bigger medical groups, guaranteed annual bonuses of $100,000 or more, did their jobs even faster.

The “unintended consequences of performance incentives”
Before I move on to what one investigator ironically called the “unintended consequences of performance incentives,” I’ll answer a question I’m sure has crossed your mind: whose money is paying for all this? For the time being, in both the US and the UK, it’s government money (which means, of course, we’re paying). The rationale, and it’s not necessarily bad reasoning given that chronic illness is so costly (think Medicare), is that as long as we’re spending these billions trying to make people well, why not see if some redistribution of the largesse can make the system more efficient.

Although these performance incentive systems are currently in place in government-funded programs only (Medicare, the Veterans Administration, and the National Health Service in the UK), here in the States the major health insurers (Blue Cross, Aetna, United) have their own performance incentive programs in place and are watching these studies carefully.

The “unintended consequences of performance incentives” referred to earlier varied from study to study. Each involved a tweak of the system to allow the doctor to get an even bigger bonus. In Chicago, aldermen frequently suffer the unintended consequences of performance incentives by doing jail time.

The unintended consequences for you personally could be less severe than jail, although theoretically you could die. Let’s review some of these unintended consequences…

  • There was a tendency to over-diagnose relatively innocuous conditions and begin treatment quickly. This is called “lowering the diagnostic threshold” and you can immediately see the danger here. You may remember I wrote about the recent revelation that the “normal” blood pressure of 120/70 had been determined during a World Health Organization meeting decades ago that was financially underwritten by a drug company introducing its latest blood pressure med. From that moment on, too many doctors started their patients on a lifetime of medication for the relatively harmless blood pressure of 140/84 (and remember BP is always higher in a doctor’s office). If a doc is getting $100 every time she lowers 140/84 to 120/70, which she can do easily with a couple of cheap generic meds, in a few weeks she can start eyeing that Caribbean cruise her husband has been badgering her about. Is your cholesterol 230? Lipitor 40 mg (generic!) will bring it to 140 and the doctor’s check is in the mail. My personal favorite of these examples was the UK nursing home that had diagnosed their frail elderly with kwashiorkor, that gruesome state of starvation you see among near-dead children during a famine. After a couple weeks of simply feeding their patients, the home received incentive bonuses for curing kwashiorkor.
  • With the over-diagnosis, there was over-treatment. Medications work faster than lifestyle changes. It’s easier for a doctor to start a smoker on Chantix and get the $100 smoking cessation bonus than it is to recommend counseling or hypnotherapy. Three weeks of generic Prozac and the depressed patient qualifies as “better” and the doc doesn’t have to spend all that bonus money subsidizing some psychotherapist. With a little imagination, you’ll notice how the serious winner in the incentive pay system is, of course, the pharmaceutical industry.
  • Along with over-treated patients, the losers in this system are two groups of doctors. One group (and I’ve written about this before) are practices with extra-sick patients who aren’t compliant about taking meds. Some programs financially penalize physicians who fail to bring down abnormal numbers and the outcome is that non-compliant patients find themselves “fired” from certain practices. The other losers are practices like WholeHealth Chicago, which has healthy patients and physicians who prescribe lifestyle changes over medications. How so you get a bonus for a smoking cessation program when you have a practice of non-smoking patients? As one British GP wrote in response to one of these studies “There is no good reason why doctors should take home less for providing good care” and branded the whole incentive pay system “perverse.”
  • The electronic medical record system is highly vulnerable to fudging data for personal gain. A dishonest doctor could simply enter 150/100 as your blood pressure on your first visit, make a note that he has counseled you to lower your salt intake, and then, on your return visit, enter your correct (normal) blood pressure. The monitoring system picks up “improvement within guidelines” and he can watch the mail for his bonus.

Personally, I think some sort of warning system to patients about these financial incentives is in order. A few amendments added to that ubiquitous Patient’s Bill of Rights you see in hospital lobbies should warn you that the hospital’s CEO will be bonused if you’re discharged early, even if you collapse in the parking lot.

Such information might convince you to have your heart transplant elsewhere. Or, doctors nationwide could wear buttons on their white coats:

• YOU 120/80, ME $100
• YOU Lipitor, ME Paris
• Your Pap test, my bonus

Be well,
David Edelberg, MD 



Leave a Comment

  1. Keith Berndtson says:

    The medical version of payola: Uncle Sam pays drug jockeys to create pharmaceutical smash hits. Integrative medicine: your FM source for the deep tracks of medical quality.

  2. PAT MINARICH says:

    Thank you for stating the truth. What a sorry mess our medical system is in. It also explains why my new (one time MD), said I needed to have blood pressure medications for a slightly elevated blood pressure. She literally said, “you need to take this medication or you might die.” It was only one blood pressure measurement that she based this on, and certainly not according to cardiac protocol. Thank you for speaking out. Pat Minarich, BSN, RN.

  3. Tricia OSullivan says:

    This is scary stuff. I am a nurse and I have never seen or heard of an exchange of money, but obviously that doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. It would be wonderful if we had good care from our medical community without benefit to them. It is always about the almighty dollar. I am confident that this doesnt happen in Whole Health Chicago.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!


Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our


The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!


Upcoming Workshops


*Yoga Therapy for Digestive Health
1-3 pm Saturday, April 22

In this workshop you will:

  • Discover how biological and environmental factors shape the health of your gastrointestinal system.
  • Learn specific breathing techniques to reduce stress and feel more grounded in your body.
  • Practice yoga postures that soothe, detox, and ground the entire GI system.
  • Practice a mindful eating exercise (on gluten-free, dairy-free, and sugar-free foods) to explore your relationship to food and cultivate fulfillment.

Insurance-eligible for WholeHealth Chicago patients.
$50 registration for self-pay or those new to WholeHealth Chicago.
Space is limited and registration is required. Register by calling (773) 296-6700.

Questions? Please email Renee here.


*Self Care for Chronic Pain with Yoga Therapy and Healing Touch
Monday May 15th and Monday May 22nd
6pm – 7:30pm
Workshop Fee $75

Are you looking for ways to manage chronic pain that doesn’t involve medication? Consider a gentle exploration in Healing Touch and Yoga Therapy that connects mind, body and spirit for overall health and wellbeing with WholeHealth Chicago’s Healing Touch practitioner Katie Oberlin and Yoga Therapist Renee Zambo.

Enrollment is limited. Register online here or by calling (773) 296-6700 to secure your spot.
Read More>>


*May Lyme Academy
Lyme & Lymph; A Source of Pain and Swelling
Tuesday May 16, 5:30-7:00pm

People with Lyme disease may experience pain, swelling and have decreased ability to move toxins out of their body. Karen Meier, Doctor of Physical Therapy, will be presenting information about the lymphatic system, how Lyme affects it, self care and manual techniques for treatment.

Registration is open to patients of Dr. Kelley, and pre-registration is required. Please call WholeHealth Chicago at 773-296-6700 or see a Patient Services team member to sign up!


*Awakened Body, Quiet Mind
An innovative workshop series for relieving mind/body stress and tapping into your true power and natural health.

Four Group Sessions with Meghan Roekle, PsyD.

Four meetings using a unique combination of embodiment meditation and mental inquiry for deep healing.

Tuesdays from 6:00-8:00pm beginning May 23rd.  Register online or call 773-296-6700


*Facial Guasha Class
The Ultimate DIY Anti-Aging Facial!
With Mari Stecker, LAc
Thursday June 8, 2017, 6:30-8PM, $65 course fee

Join us and learn a traditional Chinese facial rejuvenation technique that you can do yourself! Guasha treatment is a 2,000 year old Chinese massage technique that uses a flat tool to apply pressure to the skin to increase circulation as it moves along acupuncture channels.

Facial guasha is an easy to learn technique that:
* encourages blood flow and promotes radiance
* prevents wrinkles
* activates cells to regain facial elasticity
* drains fluids to detoxify skin and reduce puffiness
* sloughs off dead skin cells
* uplifts and tones skin
* firms up facial muscles
* minimizes dark circles
* promotes a healthy, younger and more radiant look

Space is limited, pre-registration required by calling 773-296-6700 or online.

Recent Health Tips

  • Pain And How We Perceive It

    Pain And How We Perceive It

    Many people suffering chronic pain and fatigue hear far too often the dismissive “it’s all in your head.” Dr. Edelberg has written frequently on the destructive nature of this statement, which places all the blame on the patient and none on the physician to dig …Read More »
  • Stevia and Lyme Disease

    Stevia and Lyme Disease

    Patients often ask me if stevia can treat Lyme disease. The answer is both yes and no. The question stems from a study published in 2015 in the European Journal of Microbiology and Immunology on stevia and the different forms of Borrelia burgdorferi, the bacterium …Read More »

April Sale: 20% Off Metagenics Medical Foods

Metagenics pioneered the development of science-based medical foods to help manage specific health conditions. Take 20% off these products during April…