2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Making Sense of “Controversial” Diagnoses

I’m warning you in advance. You’re entering a minefield here, with explosive views among seemingly conservative health care professionals. At least wear a helmet. Protective eyewear wouldn’t hurt either.

You wouldn’t think a slew of conditions you’ve heard about (including chronic Lyme disease, chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, chronic Epstein-Barr, toxic mold syndrome, food sensitivities, intestinal dysbiosis, chronic inflammatory response syndrome, and mast cell activation syndrome) would, at one time or another, be the topics of very uncivilized debates among professionals, with threats of lawsuits, reports to the “authorities,” and even suggestions that medical licenses be revoked.

All for the alleged crime of making a diagnosis or initiating treatment. Believe me, this is all true, though fortunately it happened to me just once.

Years ago, when I was opening what would become WholeHealth Chicago, the chief of medicine at the hospital where I’d been an attending physician (both the chief and the hospital long deceased) warned me that if I were going to become “one of those candida quacks,” he’d work to cancel my admitting privileges.

Worth noting, by the way, that I actually did become “one of those candida quacks” and have certainly treated a lot of patients over the past 25 years with candida overgrowth syndrome (now far more accepted as a valid diagnosis).

That was yesterday
But today, in some states (Illinois not among them) doctors treating chronic Lyme are facing unpleasant pressure. At the Lyme disease meeting held last month in Chicago there was a well-attended session entitled “Protecting Your Lyme Practice.” The session was chock full of advice on strategies for how you could continue to diagnose and treat chronic Lyme patients without having to deal with self-styled authority figures.

Here in the Midwest, where everyone acknowledges there are lots of ticks and lots of Lyme disease, the chronic Lyme specialists are not so much threatened as ignored. Worth noting that if you call Mayo Clinic and ask for an appointment to treat chronic Lyme, they’ll tell you they don’t treat it (same goes for fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome).

How did this conflict come about? It’s actually an interesting story, to me, at least, though you may think otherwise.

To my mind, the problem is that conventional medical education in both the US and Canada is simply stuck in about 1955 and, with the exception of a few new surgical techniques and some interesting new medications, has remained there, mired in tradition. If statistics show we’re healthier, it’s mainly because we’re taking steps to be healthy by eating better, exercising, and not smoking.

The tradition I’m referring to is how doctors actually think when confronted with a patient who has a plethora of symptoms and wants nothing more than to feel better. The way physicians interview patients and these doctors’ thought processes and note taking has pretty much stayed unchanged for almost 75 years.

How your doctor is trained
Your doctor is trained to look for disease. To do so, she first asks a litany of questions that all medical students can recite in their sleep. Then she looks for evidence of that disease via tests, imaging studies, biopsies, and the like.

Once she’s got one or more positive test results she can initiate a cure, or at least begin treatment based on evidence.

But let’s return to the litany of questions. There are virtually none that address topics such as “So what’s been happening in your life?” or “What else have you been noticing, no matter how trivial?” No questions that address how well you think your body has been functioning. Remember that word functioning. It’s key.

Unfortunately, if your diagnostic tests return negative results then woe! In your doctor’s mind, you have no disease except an emotional one. (“You must be depressed. Let me refer you for therapy. Here’s an antidepressant.”) You’re supposed to be reassured by the idea that there’s nothing wrong with you and that nothing can be done.

And so you move on, from one doctor to the next and then the next.

That’s medical thinking, circa mid-20th century. The same questions, the same tests. I recently had a patient who’d been ill for several years, had seen at least ten doctors, and literally had the same normal blood tests endlessly repeated. She would tell the doctors “I don’t need another blood count.” Leafing out her test results she’d say, “See I’ve had 20!”

And then, for far too many patients, it goes from bad to worse
Out of desperation, our patient goes online and encounters one or more of the controversial conditions listed above. Yes, the symptoms are vague (tired, achy, poor concentration), but she thinks to herself that one of them could be a possibility.  Unfortunately, though, the symptoms of chronic fatigue syndrome are very similar to those of chronic Lyme, toxic mold, Epstein-Barr, etc., etc.

“What gives?” she says to herself. “I can’t have them all, can I?”

She tries to discuss this with her family doctor but is dismissed out of hand. “You’ve been reading online about the latest fad diagnosis. There’s no such thing as ——-” (insert candida, chronic Lyme, Epstein-Barr, etc).

She finds someone–an MD, osteopath, chiropractor, naturopath, anybody–willing work with her and, lo, the tests for Lyme are positive. But wait. So are the tests for mold, for Epstein Barr, and for food sensitivities.

And now she wonders, “Could I possibly have them all?”

She starts treatment: antibiotics for Lyme, antifungal for candida, antivirals for the Epstein-Barr virus, anti-parasite meds for parasites, and probiotics for intestinal dysbiosis and she thinks she’s feeling better for a while, but then her symptoms start returning and she gets really depressed.

“Is this my life?” she wonders. “Knocking down illness after illness like the whack-a-mole game at carnivals?”

What’s going on here?
The answer comes from a relatively new specialty called functional medicine.

In a sentence: somewhere our patient’s body is not functioning properly and because of this dysfunction she’s susceptible to a variety of illnesses that normally she’d be able to render inactive and harmless.

These illnesses, recently dubbed “stealth organisms,” had likely been acquired years earlier (the average age of acquiring Lyme disease is 11, herpes-varicella-HHV-6 and Epstein-Barr are acquired in childhood and adolescence), but had been held in check until her poorly functioning body lost control and the organism woke up and started causing trouble.

Can paying attention to how the body is functioning actually cure these conditions? Well, cure is a big word, but certainly a properly functioning body can return these infections to their dormant state.

As a quick example, when we see someone with chronic Lyme disease we’ll often prescribe antibiotics initially to reduce the population of Borrelia, followed by tests to ensure all systems are functioning properly so the organism remains dormant. With stealth organisms, flare-ups can occur but they’re usually easy to treat with herbs, homeopathy, or ozone therapy rather than multiple rounds of antibiotics.

While almost all integrative physicians have been practicing functional medicine for years, the general public hasn’t known much about it. But with the prestigious Cleveland Clinic having its very own aha! moment and establishing a Center for Functional Medicine, headed by celebrity physician Mark Hyman, MD, the medical profession is being dragged kicking and screaming from the mid-20th century directly into the 21st.

Important points: Not everyone bitten by an infected tick develops chronic Lyme. Not everyone inhaling toxic mold develops symptoms. Not everyone infected with Epstein-Barr, parasites, candida, and so forth becomes clinically ill.

Why are some people able to escape all the issues linked to these conditions but you can’t?

That’s at the heart of functional medicine. A functional medicine specialist will find out where your body isn’t working right, why it’s not, and get things in good working order again.

More on all this next week.

Be well,
David Edelberg, MD

Leave a Comment

  1. Patti Woodbury Kuvik says:

    Live the “kicking and screaming” part. Does increased levels of patient knowledge play a part?
    As a thyroid cancer patient now dependent on life sustaining thyroid hormone I (and thousands like me) constantly encounter endocrinologists who rely on outdated medication guidelines based on mediocre evidence levels to frighten patients away from anything except their beloved Synthroid branded LT4. Instead of evaluating underlying causes, they prescribe more drugs to treat the side effects of over or under medication. They will then turn around and complain when their patient turns to an “alternative” care provider. I turned to my cardiologist who had a much better research-based understanding of my thyroid hormone requirements.

  2. John Heffinger says:

    Well said bravo

  3. Caron M. says:

    Great read Dr! Can’t wait till next weeks article.

  4. Walejeski Carita says:

    Great article! Still trying to find a good functional MD here in Fort Collins, CO.
    Didn’t know how lucky I was to have Dr Edelberg. Insurance covered a plus.
    Only self pay here in Colorado! First visit over $2000!!!!! I’ll keep following Dr Edelberg long distance!!!

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!


Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our


The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

Upcoming Workshops

**Winter Solstice Celebration: An evening of Acupuncture and Shamanic Healing
Tuesday, December 17, 5:45–7:30pm
Hosted by Katie Oberlin, HTCP and Mari Stecker, LAc

Course Fee: $75.00

Take a break from the hustle and bustle of the holiday season to enter the stillpoint of the Winter Solstice, reflect on the lessons of 2019, and set intentions for the new year. This will be an evening of individual and group healing, ceremony, and celebration. More →

Recent Health Tips

  • Infertility Issues? Start With The Guy

    I’ve lost track of the number of couples we treat at WholeHealth Chicago who are involved in one of the hormone injection/surgical procedure stops on the conveyor belt of infertility centers. Currently, it’s estimated that 15 to 20 percent of couples are struggling with infertility, half of them due to male factors. The infertility docs are nice enough and certainly well-meaning, but I note a Read More

  • Issues with Endocrinologists: Thyroid Approaches and Big Pharma

    My beefs with endocrinologists pretty much center on how they manage thyroid gland concerns, though they rarely win prizes for managing adrenal issues either. I don’t know any endocrinologists personally and rarely refer my patients to them. Occasionally, a patient with newly diagnosed hypothyroidism (low thyroid) will want to confirm the diagnosis with an endocrinologist. I suggest she prepare for a scolding if she’s taking Read More

  • Six Beefs With Rheumatologists

    If you find yourself in the waiting room of a rheumatologist, you’re likely there because your joints hurt and have been hurting, often for years. You’ve been getting by on aspirin or Advil for the pain, but with things worsening your primary care doctor suggests you should see a joint specialist, a rheumatologist. And because there’s a shortage of physicians in this specialty, your appointment Read More

Join our Discount Program!

Member benefits include 10% off all your purchases. Low, one-time membership fee of $25 ($35 for family).