2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Physicians And Empathy

Some time ago I read an essay by a woman who described her experiences being employed as a medical actor. She’d been hired, along with some retirees, local theater majors, and a few people who were just curious, to play the role of patient in a training program for a local medical school.

To start, she was assigned an identity that actually contained a lot of detail: “You’re a 23-year-old unemployed graphic designer with recurring abdominal pain. You’re from a small town in Iowa, where your father was killed in a car accident.” All fictional, of course, but from a medical perspective all potentially important information.

Wearing a hospital gown and lying in a hospital bed in a specially designed suite that allowed observers to watch the interaction unobserved, she’d be interviewed by a medical resident, who would then perform a physical exam and leave. Both she and the hidden observers had checklists of what was supposed to be covered and what might be overlooked.

She’d been told that her response to Question #31 was especially important to the examination. Namely, “Did the examining resident voice empathy for your problem?”

Empathy is neither sympathy nor compassion
This issue of empathy in the medical profession is a difficult one, and probably a significant factor in the public’s rising disenchantment not only with doctors but with the healthcare system in general.

Empathy as used in this setting is your doctor’s ability to share your emotions and be involved enough in your situation to share your distress. Your doctor must, at least for a moment or two, think of herself as you.

Empathy is not the same as sympathy. With sympathy, we have a concern for someone else and a wish to see them happier. We send recently bereaved people sympathy cards hoping to help them through a difficult time. We don’t send empathy cards.

Empathy is not the same as compassion. Compassion is more transcendent. It may even trigger an active desire to help. We feel compassion toward a village of starving children, but our prevailing emotion is neither empathy nor sympathy.

All this said, when I talk to new patients about their experiences with other physicians, or to longstanding patients about their experiences with specialists, I usually hear one of two things:

  • The hoped-for “I love my doctor. We’ve known each other for years.”
  • Or the opposite, “I’ve got to find someone else. She (or, when in a big medical center, they) never listened to me.”

The apparently rising tide of empathy-free physicians would be patent failures at Question #31 (“the doctor expressed concern for your problem”) and this is very worrisome.

Here’s what I think is happening
First, there’s virtually no screening during the medical school application process that might filter out students with personalities that make them totally wrong for becoming doctors. This won’t change until someone creates a screening process for the pre-med years. Frankly, it’s logistically impossible. When you see the sheer numbers of applications you have to feel compassion for the medical school admission committees.

Rush Medical College gets more than 10,000 applications for roughly 140 openings. All medical schools in the US base acceptance mainly on college grade point average and MCAT (Medical College Admission Test) scores. Yes, there’s a personal interview, but as a friend who was on an admission committee acknowledged, “They become a blur of really motivated, smart students.”

Second, testing for empathy, which British medical schools (but not those is the US) have been trying to work into their system for years, just isn’t consistent. Interestingly enough, an extensive review of personality testing results (not limited to med school applicants) published in 1983 showed that four personality traits emerged that could predict an empathic person:

  1. Even-temperedness
  2. Sensitivity
  3. Nonconformity
  4. Social self-confidence

When this article was first published, there were some stirrings in the UK that every medical school applicant should undergo psychological testing before being allowed to apply. Unfortunately, the project was simply too overwhelming and nothing came of it. But think for a moment how a doctor who isn’t listening to patients would score on a personality test. How much of health care is a mess because your doctor had the academic smarts but zero empathy?

Cultivating empathy
Interestingly, empathy can be cultivated in just about anyone. Yes, most of us can change parts of our personality we don’t like. Think about medical students being required to undergo personality testing in their first year and getting a D+ or C- in empathy. They’d then be required to take training in empathy enhancement.

Psychologist Roman Krznaric, PhD, from the UK is actually an empathy advisor to both Oxfam and the United Nations. Here are some of his researched habits of highly empathic people. When you read this list, think about the last doctor you liked, and the last one you didn’t.

Highly empathic people…

  1. Cultivate a curiosity about strangers. They’ll talk to the person sitting next to them on a bus. They find other people more interesting than themselves.
  2. Challenge their own prejudices and discover commonalities. Search for what you share with people rather than what separates you from them.
  3. Try another person’s life.  The Native American proverb “Walk a mile in another person’s moccasins before you criticize him” fits in here.
  4. Listen hard and open up. You’ve got to be really present and grasp another person’s emotional state and needs. Make yourself vulnerable–empathy is a two- way street.

Stop here. Pause for a moment of empathy for those physicians who would have failed Question #31 and those doctors with terrible Yelp reviews (“doesn’t listen”).

I suspect that many truly empathic physicians are too beaten down by the mechanics of the healthcare system to function well. In an interview in 2015, the new president of the AMA said doctors are overwhelmed by the demands of government regulators and insurance companies.

Surveys among physicians show that job satisfaction is melting away. A full 65% would leave medicine if they could afford to. Most doctors actively discourage their children from entering the profession. Added to the incessant hyper-regulation, electronic medical record (EMR) systems–forced on doctors by the government and insurance companies–are a particular point of fury.

Who has time for empathy when you’re staring at a computer screen and each of your overscheduled patients is little more than dozens of point-click, point-click, point-clicks. These days, most doctors are salaried employees of the mega-health care systems. They’re forced into user-unfriendly EMRs, given production quotas by pencil-pushers (“you’re spending too much time with patients,” “you’re behind on your paperwork”), and often waste hours of each day arguing with insurance companies over every possible aspect of patient health care, from a referral to a specialist to a prescription drug, from a diagnostic test to a hospital admission.

So what I’m saying is that before you get too angry at the doctor who isn’t listening, walk a mile in her shoes.

Come to think of it, why not take this little online quiz to help find out how empathic you happen to be.

Be well,
David Edelberg, MD

Leave a Comment


  1. Kathleen A Good says:

    I have been a patient of Dr. Edelberg for 23yrs and I can say “I Love My Dr. Edelberg! He is the Best of the Rest in the medical field!

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

BIRTHDAY

Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our

patient-portal

The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

Upcoming Workshops

**Pain Relief with Myofascial Balls
Tuesday, October 29, 6-8pm
With Renee Zambo, C-IAYT Yoga Therapist

Course Fee: $65.00
(includes WholeHealth Chicago Myofascial Release Kit, $40 value)

Does that same spot in your neck, shoulders, back or hips seem to bother you every day? Do you have joint aches and pains in the hands and feet? Would you like to learn ways to alleviate that pain and tension?

Join WholeHealth Chicago’s Yoga and Movement Therapist Renee Zambo for an evening of muscle tension release with myofascial therapy balls.

Space is limited and registration is required.
Please register online.
Call the Center for additional information at (773) 296-6700
More>>

Recent Health Tips

  • Dandruff, Fungi, and Cancer of the Pancreas

    It’s an eye-catching title, I’ll admit. But the links are quite real and further research may guide medicine in new directions of cancer prevention and treatment. It all starts in your gut microbiome, the totality of microorganisms–bacteria, viruses, protozoa, and fungi–present in your gastrointestinal (GI) tract, mouth to anus. Until recently, researchers and clinical physicians alike paid virtually no attention to the microbiome and the Read More

  • New Hope For Sinus Sufferers

    When osteopath Dr. Rob Ivker moved to Colorado in the 1980s to set up his family practice, he had no idea that when he stepped off the plane he’d succumb to symptoms of chronic sinusitis that just wouldn’t go away: stuffy nose, thick mucus, pressure behind his cheekbones and above his eyebrows, dull aching headache, and thick goopy drainage in the back of his throat. Read More

  • Director of IV Therapies Katie McManigal, BSN, ANP

    Most people at some point in their lives have had an intravenous (IV) line. An adept nurse warned you about the tiny pinch of the needle as it was smoothly inserted and taped in place.  Then the  fluid dangling above your head slowly started making its way through a tube and into your body. IVs are all over the place in hospitals. They’re seen in Read More

October Sale – Save 20% off UltraMeal Rice

UltraMeal RICE is a tasty, non-dairy, nutritionally fortified, powdered meal replacement for those who want to support healthy body composition but may be sensitive to soy.

Click here to take advantage of this month’s promotion!