2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Are Generic Drugs Different? You Bet!

Posted 05/19/2014

Bob lay wide awake at 2 AM, wondering if he’d even taken his Ambien. Melissa’s hands and feet felt cold and she was losing hair. She knew these underactive thyroid symptoms well and quickly scheduled an appointment to ask about increasing what she thought was her Synthroid prescription. Despite enjoying a relatively calm life, Peggy’s panic attacks were back and one morning she realized they’d re-started just a few weeks after her familiar Lexapro tablet began looking different, the label on the bottle now reading “escitalopram.”

Welcome to the world of generic drugs, “world” a completely accurate term when you consider that pharmaceutical companies, both brand-name (Big Pharma) and generic (Generic Pharma), market their products globally and that every country has its own rules and regulations regarding drug patents and generic drugs.

And yes, using generic drugs can save you a bundle, provided–and this is a big caveat—that what you’re taking is actually doing its job.

Bob, Melissa, Peggy, and hundreds of millions of patients around the world are on the sidelines of the incredibly complex dance among Big Pharma, Generic Pharma, and those who pay for their goods. This third group may be a health insurance company, a country’s government, or you yourself, paying out-of-pocket after shopping around for the best price.

Generic drugs have been around for decades, first appearing in the 1930s when the patents on wonder drugs like antibiotics expired and smaller drug manufacturers were allowed to copy the formula to produce generics. It wasn’t long before the wonder drugs of the 1930s morphed into the out-of-the-park cash cows of the late 20th century. This occurred because the right of Big Pharma’s brand-name drug to exclusivity, while varying from country to country, generally runs for nine years before the generic companies can move in and flood the market with their own less expensive product.

Except for comparatively low co-payments, most people have their drug costs covered by health insurance and therefore you’ll rarely know the actual price of a brand-name drug unless a particular one isn’t covered at all. In this case, you’ll experience sticker shock extraordinaire, as I did when a small tube of ointment had an out-of-pocket price of $1200.

A more familiar example is the $7-per-tablet (not a misprint) antidepressant Lexapro, the brand-name version of generic escitalopram. With millions of people taking Lexapro and its earlier version, Celexa, insurers were pouring money into Forest Labs until the generic became available at (ready for this?) two cents per tablet.

Big Pharma justifies its mind-boggling prices by claiming it’s simply recouping its research, development, advertising, and distribution costs as well as storing up money to cover the cost of drug flops. These are drugs they develop that ultimately fail in clinical trials or for whatever reason aren’t approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

You can imagine the bevy of Generic Pharma companies salivating as the patent protection clock ticked down on lottery-winning drugs like Lipitor (atorvastatin), Ambien (zolpidem), or Lexapro. You can also imagine that Big Pharma regards the Generics as a swimming pool filled with thrashing piranha. Witness the 12% drop in fourth-quarter profits at Eli Lilly when duloxetine, the generic version of Cymbalta, hit the market.

Are brand-name and generic versions the same?
We want them to be because it’s hard not to love that 99.97% price drop from Lexapro to generic. The answer, though, is slightly more complex. By law the two versions of the same drug must be close, but not necessarily identical. Big Pharma’s original version, for better or for worse, is the one you take during the first nine years of patent exclusivity.

When that ends, Generic Pharma certifies to the FDA that its version is bioequivalent (biologically equivalent) to the brand-name version. This means their product acts in your body almost like the original.


The concept of bioequivalence has been bandied about among attorneys for Big Pharma and the FDA (and similar regulatory agencies worldwide) for years. Currently, a generic drug must work at least 80% as well, or 125% better, than its brand-name counterpart.This means if you think of the brand-name drug as 100% (Lexapro is 100% Lexapro, n’est-ce pas?) then a generic can be as low as 80% of the brand-name drug or as supercharged as 125% of the original.Some observers, myself included, have issues with the honesty and openness of virtually all drug studies, whether they’re being performed by Big Pharma or Generic Pharma. A generic product may contain the right amount of medication, but its tablet coating or binding ingredient may not release the active ingredient as efficiently as the original. We won’t know this, however, until enough Bobs report insomnia, enough Melissas lose their hair, and enough Peggys report panic redux.

For a long time, when drugs weren’t as insanely priced as they are now, health insurance companies simply bit the bullet and covered expensive brand-name drugs as they were brought to market. But as prices kept escalating and more and more generics became available, insurers dug in their heels and made it difficult for doctors to prescribe new drugs.

If, for example, a new antidepressant hit the market, the insurance company would demand a good explanation from the prescribing doctor for why she chose the new one over a cheaper generic. To get the new medication covered, a doctor either had to show she’d tried two or three other drugs first (called “step therapy,” which I wrote about in an earlier Health Tip) or complete pages of paperwork or write appeal letters. This excellent physician behavioral modification program actually worked. Many doctors simply don’t bother to write prescriptions for new drugs, and the pharmaceutical reps who once filled doctors’ waiting rooms have gone the way of the passenger pigeon.

In addition, most health insurers no longer give you, the patient, an option to choose brand-name over generic. Let’s face it, if you owned an insurance company would you pay $7 a pill or opt for a version that cost two cents?

How to protect yourself when taking generics
To avoid the miseries of Bob, Melissa, and Peggy, keep these ideas in mind:

  • It’s likely not your imagination if a generic medication seems not to be working as well as its brand-name counterpart. If the FDA allows the generic to be 80% as effective as the brand-name, you may well feel that difference.
  • You’ll notice this difference only for drugs taken to relieve specific symptoms, like insomnia, anxiety, or underactive thyroid. Your doctor will have to unearth other areas where a drug may be failing you, such as blood pressure or blood sugar creeping upward and out of control. (“Are you really taking your medicine every day?” your doc may ask.)
  • If a generic drug is not on target, it’s usually because it’s weaker rather than stronger. In some cases, this can be offset by increasing the dose (10 mg of Lexapro often requires 15 mg of escitalopram). Your doctor should make this decision.
  • In other situations, you really don’t want to keep increasing your dose because then the drug starts losing its effect altogether. The sleep drug Ambien (zolpidem) is a good example. One solution might be to switch to a different drug in its class, like Lunesta. Another is to do some homework and find out which of the generic zolpidem products works most like the original. Interestingly, you can uncover this information in internet chat rooms in which patients share information. It was from a chat room that I learned a company called Qualitest made a zolpidem most equivalent to the original Ambien. From the website www.stopthethyroidmadness.com I learned the best form of thyroid replacement was either from Canada or from two small companies, Nature-Throid and Westhroid. The now-departed Dominick’s Pharmacies stocked Qualitest zolpidem, but today you’ll find it mainly at independent stores like Braun PharmaCare.
  • If you know your body and know you felt best with a brand-name medication but can’t afford America’s egregious pricing system, buy it online from a Canadian pharmacy. A branded drug from Canada is exactly the same as the branded one in the US, but a fraction of the price (30 tablets of Canadian Lexapro 10 mg is $40, while the same amount of US Lexapro is about $200). To order your meds in Canada, go to this website and click the “How to Order” tab. The pharmacists are very helpful, Canada-nice, and will verify that what you’re buying is precisely the same product as the brand-name version in the US. You then get a prescription from your doctor, fax it to Canada, and your drug appears in about three weeks.
  • If you’re happy with generics but want the best price, use Costco (you needn’t be a member to use the pharmacy), Walmart, Sam’s Club, or Target. Be aware that if you’re paying out-of-pocket for your generic, Walgreen’s is dramatically overpriced. CVS and Osco are a bit better, but not much.

This has been an unusually long Health Tip and I assume if you don’t take any prescription drugs you pressed the Delete button paragraphs ago. Remember, as always, that by keeping yourself active and healthy you’ll be less likely to be involved with the pharmaceutical industry at all, an ideal state of affairs.

Be well,
David Edelberg, MD






Leave a Comment

  1. Amy says:

    My psychiatrist has been telling me the same thing. Generic Klonopin is better or worse depending on the brand. I find myself either falling asleep during the day or experiencing rebound panic symptoms and insomnia. My psychiatrist told me that some pharmacies will order a specific brand if you ask them, but I’ve never tried it. (In my experience, Teva is the best brand of generic Klonopin.)

  2. Mark Evans says:

    If my Ambien stopped working, I’d quit staring into my computer monitor in the late evening, find a homeopathic remedy, get more exercise and sun light, some psychotherapy, but not Lunesta.

  3. PR Lundy says:

    Doc, Nature-Throid and Westhroid, now called WP Thyroid, are made by RLC Labs. ERFA, whose NDT is called Thyroid, changed plants recently and people have been complaining. Some people still do just fine with the reformulated Armour. “There is no one size fits all” in the thyroid world. PR

  4. bill says:

    a very helpful article, Dr E!

    Is a given generic usually made by just one company or might there be 2 or more companies making, e.g., generic lipitor? If multiple companies, is there a way to always buy from the same company? That seems like one way to minimize risk. What do you think?

  5. Diane Engelhardt says:

    I have this issue with losartan potassium. A generic from cvs wasn’t working. Don’t remember the mfg. I was getting it a walgreens but now discovered the mfg Walmart uses is ok for me to use. Very frustrating. Glad I check my blood pressure at home!

  6. Marie Witt says:

    I have been taking brand name Arthrotec for about ten years and it has relieved my severe osteoarthritis pain quite effectively. Three times my insurance company put me on generics (diclofenac and misoprostol) and each time the pain came back within a few days. At first I thought it was me, getting worse, with something else going wrong.

    It was the generics. Each time I got back on the real Arthrotec I became almost pain free.

    This is just a crime; when in pain, I can barely move and certainly can’t do normal activities. Even physical therapy did not help, also tried (I discovered later) at the times when I was off the Arthrotec. Can’t someone do something about this???

  7. catherine says:

    Thank you Amy, I will try Teva because I have always had adverse reactions to generic Klonopin with severe headache. I also want to tell everyone with Fibromyalgia, CFS, Migraine to research the MTHFR gene defect. This new research will help many of us with these health challanges . It also is related to cancer, diabetes, bipolar and autism. Search METHYLATION and Rich Van Konynenburg, Dr Amy Yasko and Dr. Ben Lynch. See the video by googling rich van konynenburg Sweden….Simple Methylation Protocol.

  8. Gina Pera says:

    Hi Dr. Edelberg,

    Great job!!!

    When it comes to ADHD+ medications, generics can be a nightmare.

    Given that many people with ADHD have allergies and sensitivities, they are especially vulnerable to the different colorants and binders in the generics.

    Lately, though, some really egregious generics of Concerta have been wreaking havoc with long-time users of the brand (and people new to the medication entirely).

    Their pharmacists are giving them the (profitable) party line: But they’re the same as brand.

    Pharmacies have a real conflict of interest here; they make more money on the generics.

    I urge my readers to avoid generics for ADHD if at all possible. If they cannot afford it (and ADHD itself can create that problem), then they should enroll in one of the patient-assistant programs. I’ve found them to be incredibly generous and easy for patients.

    I know Big Pharma has its problems; I’m a dedicated watchdog. But these brand and authorized generic medications are lifesavers for millions of people with ADHD. It’s “little pharma” (the pirahnas you refer to) that most worries me. They are held to little or no standards, and are absolutely shameless.

    My blog’s readers and I succeeded in getting the Mallinckrodt generic of Concerta put on the FDA’s WatchList.

  9. Jennifer F says:

    Just know that if you order drugs from Canada they are not always filled by a Canadian pharmacy.
    They may and often do come from pharmacies located in Asia and other countries FYI.

  10. KATHY says:

    I was taking the brand name Welbutrin and doing great. When I was switched to the generic unknowingly, I no longer felt great. When I checked with the doctor he figured it out that it was the generic, from then on he checked the do NOT substitute box on the script. I felt good again.

  11. Louise Witkin-Berg says:

    since patient in april always find good information and thanks for taking the time to write your Newsletter.

  12. kim says:

    Thanks again Dr. E for making us aware of this very important information. We have to be responsible for our own health and your newsletters help us to do that. The comments are helpful too. Thanks.

  13. Carley says:

    That Canadian pharmacy said they are not allowed by law to ship controlled substances prescriptions over the border. Does anyone know of a safe way to order them online with a prescription from a different country?

  14. Rebecca says:

    Please can you advise me-
    I am having recurrent depression and anxiety 17 days after my switch to Apo-escitalopram from Lexapro.
    Both ingredients listings are exactly the same according to the Australian NPS Website. What’s wrong with me? 😩

    • lecathelinais sophie says:

      Bonjour Rebecca, J’ai le même problème depuis que je suis passée à apo-escitalopram depuis 1 semaine. Qu’avez-vous fait? Êtes-vous revenue à Lexapro?

  15. Julie says:

    Excellent information. Thank you.

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our


The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Telemedicine – Now Available at WholeHealth Chicago

In order to maintain your continuity of care, WholeHealth Chicago now offers telemedicine appointments with most of our practitioners. During a telemedicine visit, you and your healthcare provider can review medical history, discuss symptoms, arrange for prescriptions, and more. When necessary, labs and diagnostic imaging can be ordered from a facility near your home, and our Natural Apothecary can ship supplements quickly to your door.

Please contact Patient Services for details and scheduling a telemedicine appointment, or to change a regular appointment to telemedicine by calling 773-296-6700.

We’re looking forward to meeting with you in our virtual consultation room soon.


Far and away, the commonest phone call/e mail I receive asks about COVID-19 diagnosis.
Just print this out, tape it on your refrigerator door, and stay calm.


• Runny nose
• Sneezing
• Red, swollen eyes
• Itchy eyes and nose
• Tickly throat
• No fever

• Runny nose
• Sneezing
• Sore throat
• Mild muscle aches
• Mild dry cough
• Rarely a low fever

• Painful sore throat
• Hurts to swallow
• Swollen glands in neck
• Fever

FLU (Standard seasonal flu)
• Fever
• Dry cough (no mucus)
• Sudden onset over few hours
• Headache
• Sore throat
• Fatigue, sometimes quite severe
• Muscle aches, sometimes quite severe
• Rarely, diarrhea

• Shortness of breath
• Fever (usually above 100 degrees)
• Dry cough (no mucus)
• Slow onset (2-14 days)
• Mild muscle aches
• Mild fatigue
• Mild sneezing

Recent Health Tips

  • No Safe Level: Lead Poisoning and Your Health

    I prefer the term “poisoning” over “toxicity” as there is no acceptably safe level of lead in the human body, just as there is no acceptable level of cyanide or strychnine. Low levels of lead won’t kill you with the swiftness of cyanide, but they will surely damage your health and, critically, that of your children, especially those under six whose physical and mental development Read More

  • Covid Immunization: Facts, Not Fiction

    If you don’t feel like reading one more word about Covid-19, you’ve got my sympathy. However, if you’re inclined, scan this Health Tip and perhaps pick up a fact or two you didn’t know. Want to jump to my take-away? It’s this: When the vaccine is available to you, take it and thank your lucky stars it’s being offered to you. One in four people Read More

  • “I Am So Bloated!”

    Susan wrote this on our WholeHealth Chicago form in the section marked “What’s the main problem?” She went on to tell me she’d been suffering for years, her stomach feeling like some gremlin was inflating a balloon every time she ate. When the bloating was especially severe, she said she looked like she was in her fifth month of pregnancy. Susan was so embarrassed she’d Read More

Join our Discount Program

Member benefits include 10% off all your purchases. Low, one-time membership fee of $25 ($35 for family).


Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!