2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Flu Shots, Mercury, and Ideologic Medicine

Posted 11/23/2010

I must say I was surprised by the degree of hostility I received when I recommended flu shots. If you want to chance it, get the flu, and die, that’s your choice. But to say I’m a dupe of the drug companies because I think flu shots are a good idea, well, expect escalation of my dander.

According to the emails I’ve received, one very popular Huge Alternative Website (HAW) says that because of my immunization recommendation I can no longer be trusted, that I’ve fallen prey to Big Pharma. Right up front, I confess I’ve not searched this website for my name, but apparently, according to its enthusiast, I did merit a dishonorable mention.

“Wait!” I protest. “Let’s have a little sense of history here. Please, someone go read poet-physician William Carlos Williams’ extraordinary essay that describes watching a child die before his eyes, choking to death from diphtheria, before you dismiss all immunizations as a conspiracy of Big Pharma. Diphtheria is pretty much history, thanks to immunizations.

Maybe you’re simply too young to remember the polio epidemics of the 1940s and 1950s. The horror of polio is well described in Philip Roth’s latest novel Nemesis . In it, he reminds us how our perfectly lovely children went from healthy to dead (yes, dead) in 72 hours if struck with polio. Terror? You can’t imagine how frightened your grandparents were about polio. The polio epidemic predates the existence of most of you, but I well remember how people wept unashamedly when Jonas Salk announced he had discovered a vaccine that prevented polio. Now polio is gone. By the way, Salk gave his vaccine to the world. No royalties, no monster check. He felt his discovery was too important for him to profit from it personally.

But back to flu shots.

Some years ago when I was specializing in geriatric medicine, there happened to be a particularly virulent flu epidemic. I clearly remember signing one death certificate an hour for three straight days–almost 70 deaths–for nursing home patients dying of flu complications. The victims were mainly older adults whose families, for one reason or another, refused to allow their parents to submit to the “dangers” of a flu shot. I assure you that experiencing this many patients dying before your eyes can alter your perspective about flu immunization.

The Huge Alternative Website bases its anti-immunization stance on the fact that vaccines contain a mercury compound, thimerosol, as a preservative. HAW’s syllogism is thus:
• Mercury is a poison (I have no problem with this).
• Vaccines contain mercury (a very very tiny amount).
• Therefore, vaccines are poison (now wait a minute!).

Mercury poisoning is a question of degree. Since mercury thermometers were taken off the market, we don’t see much mercury poisoning. Despite decades of lawsuits from patient groups and “concerned” dentists (mainly those whose income is largely derived from removing dental amalgams containing mercury), no studies have emerged that attribute a specific illness to mercury-containing dental amalgams. Neither the FDA nor the American Dental Association (both conservative to the core) recommends getting your amalgams yanked.

What about mercury and fish? Several years ago epidemiologists concluded that the health benefits of eating fish vastly surpassed the alleged dangers from the mercury they contain. They do caution pregnant women and very young children to avoid larger fish caught in polluted waters, like rivers. The Japanese, who devour incredible amounts of fish, boast one the longest life spans on the globe with no more dementia (the cage-rattler of anti-vaccine mercury ideologues) than anyone else.

You may recall the New York Times article a couple years back that stated sushi tuna contained toxic levels of mercury. That, too, turned out to be opinion, not fact.

So let’s talk a bit about ideological thinking. When you’re an ideologue, your belief surpasses evidence that might be contrary. You deliberately ignore this evidence or argue it to death. A bumper sticker some years ago from the American Chiropractic Association reading “Say No to ALL Drugs” is classic ideological thinking. Does such a slogan mean “no antibiotics for pneumonia?” “No insulin for diabetes?” Fortunately, most contemporary chiropractors don’t follow this no-drug stance.

To me, reading the Huge Alternative Website is Ideologic Medicine 101. The writers replace fact with opinion, and their opinions are potentially dangerous to your health. When you’re told to avoid all immunizations, eat no grains, and serve your family unpasteurized milk, you’re taking serious chances with your current incarnation.

Having a website, even a well-trafficked one, is not the same as having an exclusive license on reality. Whether in politics or health care, thinking that refutes evidence or cherry-picks evidence to align with its opinion is dangerous.

All I’m asking is that you be skeptical: of me, of your posh specialist at Northwestern, and of all the Huge Alternative Websites on the world wide web.

Question authority, and don’t be enthralled by any ideology, any authority figure, or any website, and maybe, just maybe, you’ll survive and live to…

Leave a Comment


  1. Lois says:

    Thank you for your insightful, well written, informative emails. Anyone who has read your previous emails would know how ridiculous it is to say you are just working for big pharma.

    Another interesting point for getting the flu shot, from NPR.

  2. Judy Kayser says:

    Way to go Dr. E! One of the very first things I think of, after told I am going to be a grandma again, is “is this baby going to be old enough to be vacinated before the flu season starts”. If not, I know I will be on pins and needles once flu season starts and they are old enough. Thanks for setting things straight.

    I recently read an article about the high death rate from whooping cough……all babies who were not immunized, for whatever reason.

  3. Margot Davis says:

    What is your opinion of the theory that the flu vaccine only immunizes against a few (or maybe only one for all I know)strains of flu, and many strains exist, so how can one assure their shot will help the strain they may contract?
    Thanks,
    Margot

  4. Dr. E says:

    Hi Margot
    The influenza virus is quite a rascal. It changes slightly every year to outsmart our immune systems and our vaccines. Scientists grow the virus, watch how its changing, try to second guess it’s plans, and develop vaccines in an attempt to outsmart it.
    Sometimes two or three strains emerge and they’ll create a vaccine that allows your immune system to develop antibodies against all of them.
    Then the next year, they have to repeat the process.

  5. Hasani Kudura says:

    Thank you for your rational and informative website. My husband and I get flu shots at Walgreens, since a bad bout of flu a few years ago that weakened us for months. We ask for mercury free—actually “preservative free” shots—and have no trouble getting them, even tho they are supposedly for children and we are over 60.

  6. Susan says:

    Thanks, Dr. E!
    All it takes is a trip down memory lane to remember a horrendous week of the flu & I’m rolling up my sleeve for that injection.

    Thanks for the rebuttal and keep those snarkies at bay!

    Thanks for helping to keep me healthy all year! Love your newsletter articles! Susan

  7. Florence Estes says:

    I’m an evidence-based believer. I’m quite susceptible to respiratory illnesses in the winter, which have often been triggered by bouts with the flu. For the past 10 years I’ve been getting the shots, and have been bronchitis free ever since! I did get the flu one of those years, so there is a small risk that the shot doesn’t cover the strain that finds you. But my odds are that 9 out of 10 years, I’m be free of flu. I’ll take that to the bank!

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our

patient-portal

The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Telemedicine – Now Available at WholeHealth Chicago

In order to maintain your continuity of care, WholeHealth Chicago now offers telemedicine appointments with most of our practitioners. During a telemedicine visit, you and your healthcare provider can review medical history, discuss symptoms, arrange for prescriptions, and more. When necessary, labs and diagnostic imaging can be ordered from a facility near your home, and our Natural Apothecary can ship supplements quickly to your door.

Please contact Patient Services for details and scheduling a telemedicine appointment, or to change a regular appointment to telemedicine by calling 773-296-6700.

We’re looking forward to meeting with you in our virtual consultation room soon.

DIAGNOSE-IT-YOURSELF: COVID-19

Far and away, the commonest phone call/e mail I receive asks about COVID-19 diagnosis.
Just print this out, tape it on your refrigerator door, and stay calm.

ALLERGIES

• Runny nose
• Sneezing
• Red, swollen eyes
• Itchy eyes and nose
• Tickly throat
• No fever

COLD
• Runny nose
• Sneezing
• Sore throat
• Mild muscle aches
• Mild dry cough
• Rarely a low fever

STREP THROAT
• Painful sore throat
• Hurts to swallow
• Swollen glands in neck
• Fever

FLU (Standard seasonal flu)
• Fever
• Dry cough (no mucus)
• Sudden onset over few hours
• Headache
• Sore throat
• Fatigue, sometimes quite severe
• Muscle aches, sometimes quite severe
• Rarely, diarrhea

CORONAVIRUS-COVID 19
• Shortness of breath
• Fever (usually above 100 degrees)
• Dry cough (no mucus)
• Slow onset (2-14 days)
• Mild muscle aches
• Mild fatigue
• Mild sneezing

Recent Health Tips

  • Protecting Yourself From Overdiagnosis

    Bill, a healthy looking guy in his mid-40s, came to WholeHealth Chicago because he wanted to get off Lipitor, the widely prescribed cholesterol-lowering drug. Bill had virtually no risks for heart disease and all four of his grandparents were still alive and quite independent, but a few years ago his cholesterol was on the high side and his doctor insisted on the Lipitor. Arthur has Read More

  • Dying In A Leadership Vacuum: The NEJM Editorial in Context

    By now, you’ve probably read that the editors of the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) published an editorial entitled “Dying In A Leadership Vacuum” that asks Americans to work together to vote out Donald Trump because of his dreadful mismanagement of Covid-19 and the subsequent deaths of more than 220,000 Americans. To call the editorial scathing would be putting it mildly. If you don’t Read More

  • IV Immune Boost: Now Is The Time

    Nobody I know was surprised when the president and many of his staff were found to be Covid-19 positive. You can only thumb your nose at science for so long before Mother Nature gets exasperated and lets you have it. To me, the real irony is this: at the same time the upper echelon in Washington is receiving gold-plated medical care, they’re pushing through the Read More

Join our Discount Program

Member benefits include 10% off all your purchases. Low, one-time membership fee of $25 ($35 for family).

MORE INFORMATION

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!