2265 North Clybourn Avenue    Chicago, IL 60614    P: 773.296.6700     F: 773.296.1131

Hormones and Breast Cancer

By noon on the day the story hit the news, I’d received a dozen emails from (sensibly) concerned patients asking what the study meant for them. First appearing in JAMA (the Journal of the American Medical Association) and then picked up by the wire services and spread around the world, the article addressed phase two of the Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) Study that was originally published in 2002.

To refresh you on the details of that study: Researchers gave 16,608 women either Prempro—which is Premarin (estrogen derived from horse urine) plus medroxyprogestin (a synthetic hormone)–or a look-a-like placebo. After 5.6 years, they stopped the study early because there was a small but measurable increased risk of breast cancer in the hormone-taking group over the placebo group.

Although the study did come under some criticism (namely, that many women might have entered the study with early-stage undiagnosed breast cancer, so that strictly speaking the Prempro did not cause the cancer), its effect was dramatic. Over the next few years there was a 32% drop in the sales of hormone replacement therapies (HRT) and, more importantly, a steady decline in breast cancer–in part, researchers believe, because of this decline in HRT use.

The current study tracks as many of these same women as they could locate (12,788) from 2005 to 2009, now completely off hormones. And the findings? Among the HRT group there were more breast cancers than in the non-HRT group (385 cancers vs. 293), a small but statistically significant difference. More worrisome, however, among the HRT group who had developed cancer was that the disease was a more advanced form (called “node positive”) than the breast cancer diagnosed in non-HRT users.

Does this mean that hormone replacement therapy is bad? That HRT will give you breast cancer, and metastatic breast cancer to boot? That no matter how physically and emotionally healthy you feel on your HRT, you should race out, bottle grasped in kitchen tongs, and bury your HRT deeply in a remote area?

Not at all.

My own issues with the original WHI study as well as this follow-up have to do with the “not real life” question that haunts virtually all clinical studies like this. In real life, there’s a significant difference between a study designed like this one and what actually happens in a doctor’s office. Let me elaborate.

No doctor would prescribe hormones just for the sake of putting someone on hormones, but that’s exactly what these investigators did. For example, no physician would ever start a symptom-free 58-year-old woman on hormones, but these investigators, mainly interested in “what would happen,” did so.

A practicing physician would review each woman’s case individually, adjust the dose according to her needs, and then discontinue the hormones when she no longer needed them. The only criteria these investigators used for starting hormones was essentially “menopausal female, regardless of age” with everyone receiving the same dose and staying on hormones continually.

Researchers would counter with “But the variations in doctors’ offices throw in too many outside factors (called “confounding variables”) that will prevent any substantive data from emerging. There will be no study, no worthwhile data.”

“Well, okay,” I’d answer, “but maybe you’re barking up the wrong tree and as a result, frightening women unnecessarily.” For example: The initial WHI study randomly selected 16,608 women between the ages of 50 and 79 to receive HRT or a placebo. Now, considering only about one third of women ever get menopausal symptoms so severe they merit HRT in the first place, we can assume that a lot of women were receiving a medication they didn’t need.

Recruiting patients is a big-dollar business these days and likely a lot of women dutifully swallowed their HRT without question. Feminists might view this as a form of low-level prostitution, and, you know, they’re right. The women in the study were recruited (with payment to both them and their recruiting physician) with the goal of “let’s see what happens if you stay on hormones.” Currently, recruited patients receive a little badge that reads “Medical Hero” (along with their check), which ironically might be pinned exactly over their breast cancer.

Doctors are paid big bucks to cull guinea pigs for research from their private practices. But in real life, women don’t seek–and doctors won’t prescribe–medications that are simply not needed.

Since menopause symptoms are pretty much limited to the perimenopause years (48-55), we can conclude that in the WHI study hormones were given to many symptom-free women (ages 56-79). I don’t fault the researchers for this decision, but it does change one’s perspective on what was actually accomplished.

Of those women who did suffer hot flashes and night sweats, none received suggestions for lifestyle and dietary changes, herbs, or other forms of alternative medicine to reduce their symptoms. But with this statement, the researcher would sputter, “That would destroy my study” and again I’d answer, “Your study isn’t what happens in my office.”

And finally, my longstanding gripe: Why do we persistently equate molecules found in the dehydrated residue of concentrated horse piss with the molecule produced by the ovary of a human female? Premarin (a name derived from Pregnant Mare Urine), produced by Ayerst Labs, is still cynically labeled “a natural product for women,” although this statement is removed from Prempro because of the synthetic medroxyprogesterone, a progesterone-like molecule also not produced by any woman I know.

Bioidentical hormones are molecularly identical to the hormones produced by the human female ovary. The estrogen in these hormones is extracted from soybeans, the progesterone from the Mexican wild yam. To date, there has been no significant research on the risks of using low doses of bioidentical hormones in women with menopause symptoms for only as long as they need them.

The only data we have come from doctors themselves, communicating with each other. And here the data are very good. I first heard of the safety of bioidenticals from Christiane Northrup, MD, who has been prescribing them for years. She believes they actually have a protective effect on the female breast. And to this day, her large Women to Women website states that the risk of bioidentical hormone is extremely low.

What should you take away from this new data emerging from the WHI study?
• Don’t take any medicine you don’t need.
• Don’t take Prempro, especially for long periods of time.
• If you have menopause symptoms, ask your doctor about bioidentical hormones.
• Take bioidentical hormones for only as long as you need them. Go off for a month once a year and if your symptoms seem to have disappeared, don’t renew your prescription.
• Don’t take any hormones at all if you have a strong family history of breast cancer. Use alternatives therapies, like Chinese medicine, instead. If you have no access to an alternative practitioner, ask your doctor about antidepressants. Both Lexapro and Pristiq (again for a limited time, until your symptoms subside) can reduce your symptoms. This is called “off-label use” of a prescription drug, meaning the FDA hasn’t approved these meds for menopause, but they seem to work anyway.

P.S. All those years ago at the start of the first WHI study, certain voices in the wilderness protested that it was basically immoral to initiate it using Premarin and Prempro. Studies from Europe had already shown a slightly increased breast cancer risk, so what would be gained by doing it twice? The researchers argued that Prempro might have additional benefits–specifically heart disease prevention. To this statement, Dr. Christiane Northrup sensibly responded, “What woman in the world would want to reduce her heart disease risk but place herself at risk for breast cancer?” And as it turned out, by the time they called a halt to the study, Premarin was shown to increase a woman’s risk of both breast cancer and heart disease.

Leave a Comment

  1. Joanne Nosko says:

    I agree with you completely and to add another dark side of the issue, no one thinks about the horses that are tied up in tiny dark stalls and kept pregnant for years. Their babies are then pulled away at such a young age they are not adoptable so most go to slaughter, as do the mares. We’re talking over 60,000 mares (most in Canada and some in the US.) and 60,000 foals every 11 months! So I’m also morally opposed to the drug and it’s manufacturer! How a drug company can be allowed to cause the abuse of these animals and then encourage women that it’s ok to put, as you say, horse piss, into their system is beyond me!

    I started taking bio-identical horemones a few months ago and the change is AMAZING! I’m sleeping better, no night sweats and my blood pressure has come down, probably because I’m sleeping!

    Thanks for the great article!


  2. Dorothy Jackson says:

    I appreciated this newsletter on HRT! I have been taking Prempro for some time and, of course, am concerned about doing so. Perhaps mistakenly; I read that you recommended going off of it once a year to see how I felt. I did this and was miserable! I did not think to consult the prescribing Doctor before going off of it, since you are a Doctor that I have heard good things about. At my annual gynecological exam, I discussed it with my Dr. He said I should not have stopped taking it abruptly. Perhaps you should have recommended this, or to not change any medication, without consulting the prescribing physician? I don’t know if I would have “heard” it, even if you had. I’ve learned my lesson. Maybe other women have too. Thought you would be interested! Thank you for the newsletter and for listening! Dorothy Jackson

  3. Dr. E says:

    There really is no harm in stopping a hormone like Premarin abruptly in that doing so won’t harm your health. However, if you’re still in the menopause transition, it’s possible (as you experienced) that your symptoms would start to return.
    Interestingly, statistics have shown that most women who stop their hormones just do so, without telling their physicians

Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, delicious and time-saving recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!

Health Tips

Dr. Edelberg’s Health Tips contain concise bits of advice, medical news, nutritional supplement and pharmaceutical updates, and stress relief ideas. With every Health Tip, you’ll also receive an easy, delicious, and healthful recipe.

When you sign up to receive Health Tips, you can look forward to Dr. Edelberg’s smart and very current observations arriving in your in-box weekly. They’re packed with helpful information and are often slightly irreverent. One of the most common responses to the tips is “I wish my doctor talked to me like this!”

Quick Connect

Get One Click Access to our


The Knowledge Base

Patient education is an integral part of our practice. Here you will find a comprehensive collection of staff articles, descriptions of therapies and nutritional supplements, information addressing your health concerns, and the latest research on nutritional supplements and alternative therapies.

Telemedicine – Now Available at WholeHealth Chicago

In order to maintain your continuity of care, WholeHealth Chicago now offers telemedicine appointments with most of our practitioners. During a telemedicine visit, you and your healthcare provider can review medical history, discuss symptoms, arrange for prescriptions, and more. When necessary, labs and diagnostic imaging can be ordered from a facility near your home, and our Natural Apothecary can ship supplements quickly to your door.

Please contact Patient Services for details and scheduling a telemedicine appointment, or to change a regular appointment to telemedicine by calling 773-296-6700.

We’re looking forward to meeting with you in our virtual consultation room soon.


Far and away, the commonest phone call/e mail I receive asks about COVID-19 diagnosis.
Just print this out, tape it on your refrigerator door, and stay calm.


• Runny nose
• Sneezing
• Red, swollen eyes
• Itchy eyes and nose
• Tickly throat
• No fever

• Runny nose
• Sneezing
• Sore throat
• Mild muscle aches
• Mild dry cough
• Rarely a low fever

• Painful sore throat
• Hurts to swallow
• Swollen glands in neck
• Fever

FLU (Standard seasonal flu)
• Fever
• Dry cough (no mucus)
• Sudden onset over few hours
• Headache
• Sore throat
• Fatigue, sometimes quite severe
• Muscle aches, sometimes quite severe
• Rarely, diarrhea

• Shortness of breath
• Fever (usually above 100 degrees)
• Dry cough (no mucus)
• Slow onset (2-14 days)
• Mild muscle aches
• Mild fatigue
• Mild sneezing

Recent Health Tips

  • Functional Medicine 101 + Introducing Dr. Parisa Samsami

    Functional Medicine (FM) is without a doubt the fastest growing medical specialty of the 21st century. Public interest and broad public acceptance of it continue to please me. Every day I hear the sentence, “I made this appointment because I wanted a functional approach.” When I ask patients how they learned about it, the answer is a variation on Dr. Google. Here at WholeHealth Chicago we’ve Read More

  • The Flu Shot: Now More Important Than Ever

    When it comes to the flu shot, I take a far more conventional approach than many WholeHealth Chicago patients expect of a doctor who considers himself alternative/integrative. It’s also worth noting that after reviewing some of the online advice warning people away from the flu shot, it’s my sense that this is frequently followed by “…and this is my product you can buy instead.” So Read More

  • Lyme Disease In Your Nervous System: Three Cases

    “Why am I limiting this to only three cases?” I wondered. Physicians who treat Lyme, like our group at WholeHealth Chicago where we see a lot of Lyme disease patients, would tell you there are so many manifestations of Lyme when it invades the nervous system that I really should list as many as possible. But to keep this Health Tip manageable, we’ll keep it Read More

Join our Discount Program

Member benefits include 10% off all your purchases. Low, one-time membership fee of $25 ($35 for family).


Join our Newsletter

Get health recommendations, recipes, medical news, supplement reviews, birthday discounts, and more!